[5.0] "A pretty short World Title match, with the first half being pretty decent before the second half descends into Hogan/Immortal melodrama that just dragged it down. The crowd was also pretty quiet throughout this one. Maybe it was for the best that this was shorter than expected."
[4.0] "Earlier in the show Eric Bischoff came out and rambled for a while for no apparent reason. All of that time could've been given to this unusually short world title match, though I can't say that it would've made things much better since they rushed through a bunch of spots and those spots wouldn't've been more interesting if slowed down. The ending was solely done to further the Sting vs Hogan feud that the latter man wouldn't be able to pay off in a match for months due to his continuing back issues."
[6.0] "A fine match with some nice spots and a nice and easy story that made sense. The ending with Hulk Hogan was a good idea, but the crowd did't really buy it and the exucution could have been a lot better. The aftermath with Sting and Hulk Hogan was fine too"
[5.0] "This was a decent match. The build to this match was somewhat intriguing, with Hulk Hogan trying to sow dissension with Mr. Anderson and Rob Van Dam. It was all an effort to try to get the TNA Championship off of Sting. The match itself was kinda disappointing. This is one of those times where having a steel cage I think hampered the quality as they couldn't do any spots on the outside as well as any sort of brawling. There were a couple of neat spots, like Sting locking in the Scorpion Death Lock on both of his opponents. For the finish, Hogan came out to give RVD a steel pipe to use as a weapon. RVD refused, but then Anderson used the pipe on RVD. Then Sting surprised Anderson by hitting the Scorpion Death Drop and winning the match. Not bad and it was kept short, but it's not any sort of standout match. **3/4"
[5.0] "Very disappointing match, nothing great happened here, aside from a few cool spots, the ending was weird, the match just ended with Sting pinning Anderson after Anderson used the pipe that Hulk Hogan threw to RVD, who refused to use the weapon."