[7.0] "This was insane. It wasn't better than the first ever Scramble Cage, but it was crazy. It's designed as a war games match, where every 2 minutes another wrestler entered the ring. There's many crazy spots such as kendo stick shots by Justin Credible, Lock choking Dixie with a belt and crashing him against the cage, they powerbomb Deranged against the cage. Izzie and Masada did some insane dives to the floor. I'm not sure if they catched Masada in his. At some moment, every Special K member enters the ring, and that might be like 10 or 12 people. And in that moment Dusty Rhodes makes a run-in to save the day. And if that wasn't enough, then Ox Baker comes to fight Dusty, which was awesome. The Carnage Crew then are able to clean the ring and they decide to end the match with a Spike Piledriver off the top of the cage through two tables. Maybe it wasn't great, but my god this trainwreck was very fun. You can't expect what will come next, I mean an Ox Baker run in and a spike piledriver that big. Tell me a better way to end the show than Dusty and the Carnage Crew having some beers over the dead body of the guy who was spike piledriven. You can tell the Carnage Crew had a blast of a night here."
[7.0] "What an absolute fucking mess (complimentary). Carnage Crew get their vengeance against Angel Dust for corrupting DeVito's daughter with an absolutely nutty top of the cage spike piledriver. There's goofy dives, 84 brutal kendo stick shots, a DUSTY RHODES run-in, an OX BAKER RUN-IN~! I would have liked some more structure - I wish they had put the Carnage Crew at a disadvantage a bit more and wish they had waited for the War Games entrances to at least end before the 90 Special K members come in, I wish the Dusty/Baker run-in didn't feel so random and out of place...but hey, regardless this was still a fun, sloppy fight. *** 1/2"
[7.0] "It's not quite at the level of the first Scramble Cage match, but it's next to impossible not to get some joy out of this crazy mess. Plenty of death defying spots (did anybody even bother to catch Masada on that dive? ), capped off by one hell of a finish. Funnily enough, I think my favourite moment of the match might not even be one of the high spots, but instead the bizarre run in from Ox Baker. Insanity."
[8.0] "One of the most absurd matches in ROH history. Carnage Crew manages to fight off like 25 members of Special K to win an insane Scramble Cage match. Also, Dusty Rhodes and Ox Baker showed up for a minute? Not sure what that was about. As is tradition with the Scramble Cage, a lot of guys did big dumb dives to the floor, with Masada in particular really eating shit. The CC won with an insane piledriver off the top of the cage through two tables."
[8.0] "Insane match filled with crazy spots and action. A super fun crowd pleasing match with everyone putting their bodies on the line to end this very important early ROH show."
[8.0] "Crazy match with everyone busting his ass off for entertaining the crowd. This was total chaos since the beginning with a lot of brawling and a lot of wild spots. Masada took a really crazy dive from the top of the cage. **** stars."