[4.0] "Maryse vs. Michelle McCool fing echt gut an, ließ aber stark nach. Für die damalige Zeit ein okays Match, es war Recht sauber. Eine Meisterleistung war es jedoch nicht (**)."
[5.0] "What the hell? It was actually a pretty decent match, which I didn't expect at all. I was really impressed with the technical aspect of it, as they had some very nice transitions throughout the whole match and Michelle sold her leg pretty well here. Unfortunately the crowd didn't care, but wrestling-wise it was pretty good."
[3.0] "Michelle McCool did better work for her character and in the ring as a heel as she was much better suited as a heel as she was a pretty bland babyface. The match wasn't awful but the womens division in 2008 was still not really anything to write home about."
[3.0] "An interesting match, i don't remember seen this 2 facing each other Mccool was the better worker and tried some crazy spots, that moonsault started great. Maryse started a leg work and continue until the end, similar to the GAB match. It's a shame that the crowd didn't care"
[3.0] "You know, it wasn't a bad match, it just the crowd didn't really care, which is unfortunate, because both tried here. Some decent work over McCool's injured leg. Maryse played her role well, but I feel McCool works better as a heel. *1/2"
[4.0] "I'll probably shock some people, but I thought this match was pretty decent. Sure, the WWE Divas aren't known for having quality matches, but this one can be considered a very small exception to the rule. It wasn't a good match either, but it's better than nothing. [**1/4]"
