[2.0] "I don't/didn't really care about this. I'm not an expert, but I'm pretty sure if the lumberjacks get involved in the match while it's in the ring (Natalya trying to drag Michelle out the ring), its a DQ. But it doesn't matter, don't like the Women's title being killed off but whatever.."
[2.0] "I absolutely did not think this match would be this bad. For me, McCool is overrated, but still not bad, and Melina might even be a bit underrated. But this was just terrible. Almost every single move they make is awkward and sloppy. I think there are more mistimed moves during the match then there are properly executed ones. Even the lumberjills are sloppy and mistimed. There's a point where someone throws a punch at someone else (I couldn't tell who) in clear camera shot. She obviously thought it was time to start the distraction melee, but she was early, so the second person catches her punch and is like "Not yet, not yet." Then things spill out again half a minute later, and everyone brawls. A really bad, pointless stipulation along with sloppy ring work and mistimed move after mistimed move. This one was ugly."
[5.0] "It is really a shame that talented workers in the womens division at the time were given so little to work with and this was another match that a few years later would have been a lot better than what we got."
[4.0] "This was not their best match and didn't represent at the time the best both could offer, aside from Mickie James and Beth Phoenix, these two were probably the best on the roster and unfortunately the stipulation here didn't do them any favors."
[2.0] "A sorry state of affairs when this is the big unification match. 6 whole minutes, I feel sorry for these ladies because they can do so much better"
[4.0] "Lol at Michelle randomly slapping Rosa Mendes. Melina was really over with the crowd, and it was refreshing to see the Divas getting those kind of reactions. I don't think the match should've been a lumberjill match, it kind of hurt the flow of the match, and I prefere their other matches. This one was pretty decent. *3/4"
[4.0] "This was decent but I preferred their match at NOC 09 more. There were some good moves and the crowd was hot for Melina. The lumberjills were unnecessary and hurt the match for me."
[7.0] "Good match, wrong title won - not the wrong wrestler necessarily, but the Divas title had the infamous butterfly design on its main plate, so fans disliked that championship. Michelle McCool and Layla pulled off a big swerve to distract Melina and get both belts to the team known as LayCool."
