[7.0] "The entire show was a slog to get through, but at least the main event is good. Big Show has to be the most pointless inclusion and nobody cares when he is screwed out of the match early. It's considerably better with Jeff Hardy, RVD and Chris Jericho left. Jeff next to go which made sense as he was selling last weeks beat down from 3 Minute Warning and RVD and Jericho have a solid finish with Triple H looking unhappy when RVD wins to set up their match at Unforgiven."
[4.0] "It was a decent match with some cool spots. They're trying to push RVD but they're a year too late for that. He's lost pretty much all the momentum he had although he's not good at the microphone, he's still a good wrestler and has a great fanbase. As for the match, I didn't like some of the eliminations as they seemed forced and rushed. It was a forgettable match."
[5.0] "Als Big Show eliminiert ist, wird es seriös. Besonders die Endsequenz mit Jericho und Van Dam allein ist relativ vorzeigbar. Alles in allem ist aber auch diese Partie ein Beleg für eine relativ dünne Personaldecke im Titelpicture, nachdem im Roster-Split einige Top Dogs zur blauen Marke gewandert sind."
[7.0] "Just look at the talent in the Ring (minus big Show really but who cares). Jeff RVD and Jericho put on a great match in what seems to be a good end of the year for RAW Main event matches (more later). But a really solid match ***½"
