[3.0] "Was picking up some steam and the crowd was actually really behind Tamina here but, it wasn't the most awe-inspiring match as Beth looked like she just didn't want to be there anymore (she left 8 months later) and the later stages of her career you can tell she just wanted to move on, and Tamina was a bit too green to get A+ chemistry with Beth. It was a C- effort. The match was getting better but, the rushed, predictable at the end, could of potentially saved it from being serviceable to not just a good showing at all for the girls."
[4.0] "Tamina, with her own impressive physique, manages to keep Beth Phoenix busy for at least a moment, before she too falls victim to the blonde powerhouse's current dominance."
[3.0] "It was just a bad and boring match between both women with bad in ring action and character work between each other and there's nothing to write home about."
[3.0] "Just a very subpar match. In my opinion, Beth was never that good, and at this point in time, Tamina had no identity of her own. She was literally just a carbon copy of her Dad with no originality of her own. That doesn't make a star. And considering how quickly that'd all get erased after Snuka's murder was reevaluated, it makes it even worse in hindsight. The only real highlight is Tamina taking a hard bump to the outside. I'm not sure if she was supposed to take that bump or if she slipped, but it was effective. Other than that, standard stuff with a decent bit of rest holds. One competitor is average at best, the other is just trying to be her Dad. So it was a recipe for a mediocre affair."
[6.0] "Not the greatest women's match but it was okay. The women's division was a joke at this time, and the Divas championship too. The match was a little boring but no botch. A match without botch are very rare at this time! Tamina could win!"
[4.0] "An alright match, I like Beth Phoenix a lot, probably one of my favorite womens wrestlers in the companies history, Tamina looked alright, back when she was a decent face to challenge for the title"
[5.0] "I didn't expected anything from a Tamina vs Beth Phoenix but it's was pretty solid the only problem was the match went a little too long and the crowd was dead"
[3.0] "Not the greatest match, but this was back when the diva's matches were used for "bathroom breaks". Good ending sequence, but other than that a pretty boring match. Wasn't given a lot of time, and wasn't put in the match slot to succeed."