[8.0] "So I can understand why some folks might not be high on this match, it's a little too long and some of it is just aimless brawling, but I thought there was an awful lot to like here. 2 Cold is such a great heel and always pulls out cool stuff, and Sandman is a weird but oddly good partner just for the juxtaposition. PE do some good brawling, I liked this overall."
[7.0] "For how heated the matches between these 4 got with the steel cage match including Mikey and New Jack, they made the choice to start this off with a dance-off pre-match and it's truly incredible. The match itself is a really fun brawl, grabbing anything they can to smash over the other's head. There's an unintentionally hilarious bit of everyone doing big dives off the top rope in succession and then Sandman slingshots over the top to do a running forearm. Grunge and Sandman get some crazy blood in this one, loved the finish of Sandman practically knocked out leaning against the ropes and Rocco Rock accidentally hits the Drive-by on Grunge and Sandman just collapses into the pin. One of those incredibly fun ECW tags that's just action for the whole thing and a fun bit of comedy to go with it."
[5.0] "It was hard to be surprised by anything after a great Mexican death match. Johnny Grunge and Rocco Rock had a rather specific style, their brawls are often monotonous and not very interesting, and I think the quality of the match more often than not depends on their opponents. The segment before the match was hilarious, the dancing Sandman is something awesome. The brawl though was fun, using various items including even food, besides a lot was on the line - including the titles and title shot on Mikey Whipreck's Heavyweight title, but it was all very long. A decent fun match that was given way too much time nonetheless. Sandman was the absolute star of the match."
[5.0] "A decent brawl here, although it didn't need to be quite as long as it was, and it looked like both the crowd and the Public Enemy lost interest towards the end. Fun for what it was, and pretty much exactly what you'd expect from these guys at this time."