Chris Jericho vs. CM Punk vs. John Morrison vs. R-Truth vs. Rey Mysterio vs. The Undertaker

[6.0] "6 Points or 3 stars, went into it not knowing what chamber it was so I still got to enjoy the mystery of who wins until Shawn showed up. Taker did well considering the burns. R Truth had a brief but solid showing in his first EC, John did well in his first here too lasting longer & getting to show off his finish and secure a pin. Commentary did a good job of adding context, like JoMo's ankle being injured prior to the match or Jericho having recently beaten Taker with the codebreaker when he hit the move towards the end of this match. Rey was in perfect form per usual, flying around and getting manhandled in equal measure. Rare case of someone being small enough for Punk to work a Big Man style against. Mid match Punk promo was good added showmanship, Jericho was the king of taunting overall though clearly thriving in his rude & calculating heel role. John and Rey brought the athleticism, Jericho and Punk brought the psychology, Truth got to rap & look decent before eating a pin, Taker got to run through some hits before HBK stole his thunder (and allowed Jericho to steal his championship)"

[8.0] "Good match. Ending was great way to set up the story of Shawn Michaels and the Undertaker part 2. Great to see Chris Jericho finally win a chamber after being one of the best performers every time."

[9.0] "Fantastic chamber match between everyone involved with fantastic action and performances from each man and it's home to the best elimination chamber ending ever with Shawn Michaels breaking in from underneath the chamber to cost Undertaker the match and World Heavyweight Title to Michaels' most hated rival Chris Jericho as a way to make Undertaker give Michaels his WrestleMania rematch against him."

[6.0] "A much better chamber match than the one before, and a good match in general, but still not what I'd call a great one. There is still far too much one on one time in this match. There are very few points where more than two people are moving around at once, which makes it very bland to watch. It comes close to undermining the concept of the match. However, on the back of Mysterio's work, Jericho's psychology, and the Undertaker's intensity, they pull together a good match. Mysterio's head first bump into the glass is a highlight. Truth was just there to fill out the numbers, and Punk and Morrison did not have a shining performance at all. A good match that, of course, is insanely important for the Undertaker vs. Shawn feud, but still was lacking in many ways."

[7.0] "Great action from RTruth and Punk to begin this match, but Truth gets eliminated pretty quickly. Thanks for comin R truth. This gives punk a chance to cut a promo. Then Rey is in, who's always great, especially a good dance partner for punk. He eliminates punk. Thanks for coming CM punk. Next is Jericho, another all time great opponent for Rey. John Morrison is looking very impressive in this match, as he does for the other elimination chamber matches I've seen him in; very welcome on the card for this type of match is Johnny Nitro. He knocks out Rey, giving this match a very gauntlet-like feel which works well. And there were no rope breaks in this one! Gets an extra point for that. Somehow Shawn Michaels sneaks in and spoils the match for Undertaker, setting up one of thier great Wrestlemania matches."

[9.0] "one of my favorite chamber matches, one of the best endings that has stayed with me. they set up undertaker and Shawn Michaels in a great way. also for undertaker to perform even after getting third degree burns is insane to think about. Rey getting a beating was intense too! Morrison is my favorite with a good outing"

[7.0] "Lets talk about the good and the bad. The good - John Morrison getting a nice showcase, making it to the final 3 and only getting eliminated after a brutal chokeslam on the steel. I remember at this time Morrison was getting good reactions as a face and I thought it was a shame he never got to that main event level. The guts of the Undertaker to perform the way he did after receiving third degree burns is incredible. Jericho playing his character to perfection, the part where he left the pod he was hiding in and then ran back after Taker sat up was gold. Michaels interference also continued the story between him and Taker. The bad - CM Punk being eliminated so early, he was one of the best heels even at this time and he was wasted in this match. Mysterio also didn't get to do much. Truth was a wasted entrant, no-one thought he had a chance of winning."

[9.0] "This is a great chamber match with some fun moments with rey taking a beating shawn costing the undertaker the title and this is just so good. ****1/2"

[8.0] "Fantastic Elimination Chamber match, though not without its few flaws. The elimination order was a little iffy for me, but it worked mostly. Punk got eliminated way too early but he made the most of his ten minutes in the match. Morrison and Rey got to show off their dope offenses, especially Morrison who even survived till the final three. Jericho was my MVP of the match without a doubt, ruling the second half with his awesome smug expressions, quality character work, and a great heel performance. Finally of course, HBK stole the whole show by costing 'Taker the match to kickstart their glorious WM feud. [****]"

[10.0] "Important and Awesome moment in the Shawn/DX Vs. The UnderTaker Rivalry. Punk, Mysterio and Morrison also shined throughout this one."

[7.0] "This match was a very cool Elimination Chamber Match with some defaults obviously like always in that type of match, but I think the whole thing is well booked to arrive to the ending with Shawn Michaels giving the win to Chris Jericho. I was a little bit disappointed that Punk got eliminated so early because he eliminated Truth very early and could have been playing a big role here. ***1/2"

[7.0] "This was a very good Chamber, I personally preferred this one to the opener. The crowd was much more involved and the rhythm was really cool, I was never bored and it was mainly because there were only very good workers here. But apart from the good action, there was also the booking of the eliminations which I thought was great. CM Punk was excellent in the short time he stayed, the same for R-Truth who served well to get squashed, Rey was the MVP of the match in my opinion with a big performance, Morrison was impressive too and I didn't expect him to go so far in the match, Jericho was fantastic as always and Undertaker did a good fighting champion performance. The final between Taker and Jericho was really solid, as the final-three with Morrison who was clearly very good alongside the two legends. And how to talk about this match, without mentioning this legendary ending with brilliant storytelling. The intervention of Shawn Michaels who cost Taker his title to go in the main event of WrestleMania with him, we all know the rest and that's what makes this moment more beautiful. Jericho's victory was anecdotal and took a back seat, but sometimes you have to sacrifice some people so that others make the buzz, and that's what happened here so I don't have a problem with that. Solid main event."

[7.0] "Punk eliminated R-Truth in first five minutes. I think that R-Truth could be eliminated in more brutal way because he interrupt Punk's promo. Then Punk could continue to sell his fantastic mic skills. Mysterio as the next entrant was good choice. I love his high-energy start and after that Punk started destroying him in a brutal way. Mysterio comeback to the match and sat Punk down on the top turnbuckle and threw him on the steel floor with top-rope hurricanrana for the pop. This sequence was awesome. But CM Punk was eliminated too soon. Jericho and Mysterio put almost the same schema but it wasn't as good as with Punk. Morrison came into this match without any reaction from the crowd. It was Morrison who bring the great athleticism to this match. Morrison eliminated Mysterio which was pretty weird. Undertaker was the last one who entered the elimination chamber. I like how Jericho played the fear of the Deadman and Morrison played a young hungry fearless man. The spot when Jericho go back to the chamber after Undertaker looked at him was briliant. Morrison has been eliminated. Jericho and Undertaker threw finishers at each other and then Shawn Michaels showing up and cost Undertaker the match. What an awesome finish! This wasn't as good as the previous chamber from that night but it was better for moments. Respect for The Undertaker because he working with burning chest. ***1/4"

[9.0] "Downsides to this match: R Truth is a lame duck entry, CM Punk is eliminated far too soon, and when HBK appears at the end Cole calls it in the stupidest and most ridiculous way possible. Also Taker is maybe slightly off his game, probably because he was almost lit on fire during his entrance (seriously, youtube that! ). But apart from that this match is really excellent, there's a ton of good action, Punk's midmatch promo is great, and Jericho steals the show with some fantastic character work, I love him trying to hide from Taker in the pods, wonderful sequence. Overall I liked this a lot, an underrated match in the larger scheme."

[9.0] "Very underrated match. Might very well be my favorite Elimination Chamber match ever. This one was almost polar opposite to the other Elimination Chamber match that night. Every superstar got their time to shine (R-Truth maybe not so much). Entertaining almost all the way from top to bottom"