[4.0] "A weak tag match between both teams with messy action and psychology between everyone involved, far from the best tag teams ever that were involved here, and the elimination was also weak as well."
[4.0] "I wanted this match to be much better than it was. Three of the greatest tag teams of all time in this Survivor Series match. Some good action but nothing amazing."
[5.0] "It's an okay match with some decent action, but like the other Survivor Series Elimination match it just doesn't feel very important and none of the featured tag teams are really booked that well because the first four eliminations happen fairly quickly and are one member of each team. I don't know, I think a four corner elimination with the tag titles on the line would have been better than this. The post match was better when the Hardys and Dudleys come back after Jeff won and gets attacked by RTC and both teams join forces to put Val and White Socks through a table."
[7.0] "Enjoyed this one. Sure, it felt rushed at times and there were one or two confused spots; Goodfather and Buchanan in particular just look out of their league compared to everyone else. But Bubba Ray brilliantly played the heel team against each other, and then Jeff clinching the underdog victory, despite what looked like an injured arm, was a nice touch. Of course, seeing RTC eat wood post-match was also a plus."
[6.0] "Much more energetic than other Survivor Series Matches on this show. Even though they only had 10 minutes they were able to get some excitement into it with the advantage changing hands often until the last man. Bubba had a very good moment in the bout, plus Jeff worked out nicely as the sole survivor."
[4.0] "There were a handful of decent spots in this match, but 10 minutes is far too short for a Survivor Series match. Like a good few matches on the card it was the skeleton of a good match that never really got going."
[4.0] "Bull Buchanon and Buh Buh start. D-Von gets beat up next then he hot tags to Matt who cleans house but Edge gets him with the edge-o-matic for the first elimination. D-Von rather quickly falls victim to the unprettier of Christian which leaves Jeff and Bubba against 4. Jeff works over Christian and hits a moon sault, but ends up getting posted. Bull tags in and misses a blind charge, and Jeff brings in Bubba who goes nuts. Edge tries helping out but spears Bull by mistake and Buh Buh gets a pin to ease the pressure. Edge goes bye bye after a mistake by Christian and a buh Buh bomb then Buh Buh turns into a DVD from the Goodfather. Jeff Vs Christian and Goodfather. Christian works on Jeff then misses something which lets Jeff get the swanton to eliminate him. Goodfather goes for the ho train which hasn't worked in any of the ppv matches he's had all year and Jeff pins him to finish. RTC attack and the Dudleyz and Hardyz run back and brawl. Tables for everybody. These matches don't have the same magic as years past."
[4.0] "It's kind of corny. Heroes defeat villains. It's been a lot of times. I don't think Hardy should have won here, because the team of heels was exposed as idiots.. **"
[6.0] "This match was all about the story, wish was pretty classic, but nicely told. With Matt Hardy and Devon Dudley being eliminated fairly quickly by Edge & Christian and Bubba and Jeff having to team together against the odds. Bubba come back sequence was very cool, he looked one step ahead of everyone and it was a fun moment. Jeff then plays the ultimate underdog, picking an upset victory after some misscomunication."