[9.0] "Great TV match, particularly for the era, as two of my favorite workers fight it out. Bonkers to think Vince was in the process of discarding both these guys, as they obviously have a lot left in the tank."
"It's not bad. I enjoyed it. Watched this match as part of the Wrestlefest 1994 Video Tape. Solid match. Nothing to write home about. Standard match with Macho picking up.the win."
[7.0] "Silky smooth TV wrestling, giving Savage a win on the road to WrestleMania X. It's wrestled with full awareness of that goal in mind, yet still climbs high on sheer skill and quality of execution. ***1/4"
[8.0] "now this is a great match, they're both great workers a bit past their prime, very quick match and Randy's selling is always amazing, very competitive vibe. (****)"
[7.0] "Two of the few guys from the Golden Era who successfully transitioned into the New Gen. Martel, who is never talked about which is criminal, is great as always. Savage is great as always. Put the two together and you get a outstanding TV match. Really fun."
[9.0] "Man this is excellent, I had highish expectations and this exceeded them with ease. Both are on fire here and things escalate at such a timely pace, they're proficient at this! Just two of the greats who had fantastic chemistry together. The only true flaw is the commentary features Vince McMahon. Finish is DEFINITIVE. Loved it, 9.25."
[7.0] "A great competitive bout between two of the only few WWF 80s guys in the company at that point. Savage of course was far from his heyday here, but never really stopped being fantastic no matter what anyone may say about him. And Martel is always a safe bet for a good lengthy TV match. A mini-classic on Superstars here. [***1/2]"