CAGEMATCH » Matches » Nigel McGuinness vs. Samoa Joe

Nigel McGuinness vs. Samoa Joe

Match

Match Data

Fixture:

Date:

18.09.2004

Promotion:

IWA Mid-South

Match type:

Singles

Event:

IWA Mid-South Ted Petty Invitational 2004 - Tag 2 (Card with guide)

Notes

- Dies war ein Viertelfinalmatch des Ted Petty Invitationals 2004.

6.67

Current Total Rating (?)

Valid votes: 17

Number of comments: 7

10.0

9.0

8.0

7.0

10x

6.0

5.0

4.0

3.0

2.0

1.0

0.0

Average rating: 6.71 [17]

Average rating in 2026: 8.00 [2]

Average rating in 2025: 7.00 [3]

Average rating in 2024: 6.50 [2]

Average rating in 2023: 7.00 [2]

Average rating in 2022: 6.50 [2]

Average rating in 2020: 6.50 [2]

Average rating in 2019: 5.00 [2]

Average rating in 2014: 7.00 [1]

Average rating in 2013: 7.00 [1]

Your Options:

Other:

Latest comments of the CAGEMATCH inmates

ElmoLikesToSimp wrote on 05.04.2026:

[8.0] "This was a very good match! Nigel & Joe had good chemistry here, and they worked off each other well. Nigel did this cool counter where he was put in a bulldog-type hold on the mat, but he'll headstand out of it and grab his own headlock/bulldog. He's done this numerous times in other matches, but it was nonetheless cool to see here. Samoa Joe made Nigel tap out in what was a very pleasing match!"

conker8 wrote on 11.03.2026:

[8.0] "This is a really good match, much different from Joe's war with Roderick Strong. Kingston on commentary."

CMgab wrote on 30.07.2023:

[7.0] "Good match, the did some good technical wrestling and they battered each other with very stiff shots here and there. The finish was very good too with Joe resisting to Nigel's attempts at submitting him and putting on his Rear Naked Choke to get the McGuinness to tap. ***3/4"

joethom wrote on 11.09.2022:

[7.0] "A good, stiff match. It is a early 2000s indy match, so a bizarre mix of styles with no pulled strikes. A good victory for Samoa Joe, two great matches."

RatingsMachine wrote on 03.04.2019:

[4.0] "The match was OK, although it was very obvious that Joe, for understandable reasons, wasn't going all out. Because of that, the match was underwhelming and disappointing."