[0.0] "This, just like every other bad match that was on this show was just total waste of time, no one looked good nor motivated either in victory or defeat, Big show's dominance looked very weak, Jindrak and Reigns were bad, and Angle deserved so much better."
[4.0] "Simple. Basic. Mediocre. Just felt a bit lifeless with Show being worked over quite boringly. Big Show's push on Angle and the F5 on Jindrak were the only real highlights."
[3.0] "Ne diese Zeit wo Kurt mit Luther & Mark teamte war echt schrecklich für Kurt in seiner Fähigkeiten. Das hier war echt ein mieses Three On One Handicap Match (*3/4). Fast so schlecht hat es auch der WON gesehen und (*1/2) gegeben."
[2.0] "Holy shit this is actually giving Judgment Day and GAB a run for it's money for worst PPV of 2004. This is 5 straight matches in a row that I'd consider a 2.0 or lower. Big Show vs Angle itself is usually a really solid match between two guys with chemistry but turning this into a handicap match took away any of the possible positives."
[4.0] "It was fun at first when Big Show was manhandling all three guys, but the structure wasn't good enough to make it feel more than a simple TV match. Plus at one point everybody started getting in the ring without caring about the tags and it left me frustrated a bit."
[1.0] "This was a huge waste of time for everyone involved, Big Show, Kurt Angle, even Mark Jindrak. It was about on par for what Luther Reigns deserves, but why force the poor live audience to see this? Absolute stinker of a match, did nobody any favors and wasn't any fun."
[2.0] "This is just seriously mailed in. At least a definitive win for the Big Show like this surely had to be the end of this awful feud and that booking decision is somewhat hilarious. It's a terrible use of a guy like Kurt Angle and his stable was dragging him down. Big Show winning the match with an F5 thankfully didn't become a regular finisher. This has been an awful show so far."
[1.0] "This match was absolute crap, Angle seemed checked out and bored with this whole feud, Jindrak and Reigns could not work with Big Show and Show was just there to lazily dominate."
[2.0] "It was certainly a choice to put Kurt Angle, of all the people, in this "handicap match involving babyface big guy" trope match. All this will do is make Angle look weak, because it's not exactly like his two partners will fall any further. Angle's in-ring is great as always, but the finish is highly predictable and the other 3 participants seem happy just to burble along and accept that this won't get over."
[3.0] "Mediocre as hell. It's sad to see Angle being put in a throwaway match like this given his talent, but his efforts were enough to make this at least somewhat watchable. Still a pretty poor match. *1/2"
[2.0] "Bad match. It was so boring until the obvious comeback by Show to win the match. Show using the F5 as a finisher was something I had forgotten about. This was one of the worst Angle matches you'll ever see, but it was not his fault. Show looked exhausted after about five minutes. At least it put an end to this storyline. Jindrak taking the pin was done to protect Angle, which was fine. Terrible (3/4*)"
