[4.0] "It somehow doesn't do justice to the Dudleyz' legacy to relegate them to such a one-trick pony, as happens here at TNA. The match seems disjointed and uninspired, with AMW also failing to shine. Without the obligatory tables stipulation, this team constellation could certainly have produced a better match."
[3.0] "It's a bad brawl between both teams with most of the action and spots with all the tables being very weak despite the crowd being somewhat into it."
[6.0] "I kinda enjoyed this one, partially because Team 3D felt fresh here with the TNA crowd which helped keep the energy. It's a shame they didn't build on this one."
[0.0] "Not being a title match is a complete booking failure. There was no reason to not do it. It was equally terrible having Team 3D win two straight. The promo that Team 3D gave before the match was really misleading. They put so much emphasis on the importance of winning the NWA tag titles and what it would mean for their career. Not once was it made clear by them or commentary that it wasn't for the title. Only when they match began. Pure late stage WCW nonsense. The match itself wasn't very good either. It was very slow and plodding."
[5.0] "An okay match that likely would've been better under a different stipulation. They did well for a tables match but it still ended up being flatter than anticipated."
[9.0] "Maybe I'm predisposed to enjoy a match between these two teams but I thought this was pretty great, it wasn't the neck and neck competitive match it could have been but AMW got their shots in and 3D looked strong, which was the point. Some unbelievable shops from Ray and some nice looking brawling and table spots, I was entertained."
[4.0] "Someone is the booking office remembered the Dudleys are only over because they put people through tables so booked this match. If you have seen a Dudleys tables match before then trust me, you don't need to watch this one."
[5.0] "Two legendary teams met in a match. Then it was a dream match. The match, by the way, turned out to be quite good. It's a shame of course for AMW. They were squashed as some losers... But they are Champions. Apparently Dudley is the next champion."
