[9.0] "I'm a sucker for a great battle royal, and this is an awesome one! From seeing unusual faces from the midcard to the strategic elements of Evolution working together and their enemies waging war on their alliance, the really top notch final four and the great final two battle, awesome stuff."
[8.0] "Really solid tv battle royal with Randy Orton's surprise win bringing something fresh to the main event scene as well as it continuing some really good long booking with the Evolution faction. I just thought it was really well put together with some memorable and surprising moments like Rhyno hitting Batista with the gore and Maven getting the shock elimination on Flair which was another feather in the cap for him in these type of matches. Loved the stare down when Jericho outsmarted Edge as there had been teases of an Edge heel turn for several weeks by that point. Orton and Jericho was a fantastic pairing for the final two and kept things dramatic till the very end."
[6.0] "As good as a Battle Royal can be, with smart booking, Evolution and Christian/Tomko respectively gang up to succeed, Kane rules as a monster, and Jericho showing off his experience and brains. The ending promised great things at the time."
[7.0] "An incredible piece of booking, this is how a Battle Royal is done. Regal was not 100% so he was out first, then comes Tomko because the lack of experience, followed by undercarders eliminated by the much experienced guys. Continuing the Matt-Kane, Batista-Jericho feuds, even planting the seeds of the 3 Way Ic title match for SummerSlam, Jericho was smarter than Edge Trying to push Rhyno and Maven And an exciting final 2, a competitive bouth with well cordinated near falls, and starting the Orton vs HHH storyline, Randy looked soo good"
[8.0] "This is a pretty random battle royal and often forgotten, but it really is a great one. The proper number of people, the proper duration, and a nice story overall, without it being super predictable or boring."
