[6.0] "Shane has a good history with Last Man Standing matches because he is insane, and this one is no different. While certainly not nearly as good as the one he'd have against Kane years later, it was still a good performance. It was overbooked with Vince and Test coming out, but I guess they figured that was the only way to make it feel like Shane'd logically have a chance. Also doesn't make Show look great considering he had Shane beaten a bunch of times. It is heavily reliant on the big spot at the end. Without that, this would have been a 5 point match, but it so huge and so memorable that is worth the boost. A car crash match with one massive spot, but it is a really fun one too."
[8.0] "It might not have been the best wrestling match in the world, but my goodness was it an amazing spectacle. Shane's tactics are actually pretty smart at the start of the match where he kept himself out of reach and gets a lot of weapon spots and they even tease an impossible clean win when Shane uses ether to knock Show out but then Vince shows up and hits his son with a chair and things look really bad for Shane after Big Show recovers and he dominated and started playing with his food. Test shows up after awhile and they end up brawling on the stage and the finish with Shane jumping off the top of the tron looked unbelievable. It's an insane all or nothing spot Shane became best known for as a performer. It's a much better match than the one at the previous year's Judgment Day simply because it was a better story and Shane is easy to route for here."
[8.0] "This was just for the fun of it, and it works. Shane and Big Show tell a story that just makes perfect sense for this type of match. The spots were cool and of course the ending was crazy. And the build up to that spot was awesome and it flows super well."
[4.0] "The spot at the end of this match is crazy and very memorable, but the rest of it is slow and not very interesting. Big Show beats down Shane for a lot of the match, and it is pretty boring. Test comes in and helps Shane, which eventually leads to the awesome elbow drop off the structure. **"
[5.0] "I didn't hate this but I felt like the end took a really long time to set up (understandably) and hurt the flow a little. Shane's big dive was sick but as far as hardcore matches ago, I wasn't crazy into this."
[4.0] "I don't dig these Shane hardcore matches. I'm not invested in neither a billionaire's kid nor Big Show who lost any excitement about him since he became the WWF Champion. Everything is basically a filler until Shane jumps from a high place and that's how most of his bouts work."
[7.0] "I liked this honestly lol. Ive only ever seen that big leap at the end of the match but the match overall is fun. Starts off hot then Shane brings in a rag with something on it that temporarily knocks out the big show before Vince makes a run in and knocks Shane out with a chair. It slows down for a while like test runs out to save shane then from there they all go to the entrance ramp to set up the huge spot at the end. Legendary moment and an awesome way to end the match. 3.5/5"
[4.0] "Big spot at the end, but I hated this match. Big Show was booked horribly this year, and this match is one of the better examples of that. But it let Shane jump off something tall, and people like that, so I guess it's remembered more fondly by some people."
[7.0] "One of the buggest bump's at the time and still to this day. Shane was always doing crazy spots he had no need to do, love him for that. The match itself, quick paced hardcore action as you'd expect."
[8.0] "This match is not good on a technical level, however is highly elevated by the jaw-dropping elbow drop from Shane that was well set up, and the match and great character work and storytelling from each contender."
[5.0] "Big Show is there to get revenge on Shane for Mania 17. Typical match that one might expect with Shane getting help from Test and then Shane doing his big spot at the end to win. Wasn't too shabby."
[6.0] "A match mostly known for its ending. Wasn't tremendous and wasn't terrible either. Just an average Last Man Standing Match with an insane spot."
[6.0] "It's the usual Shane match highly elevated by that one huge spot he ends up doing. The 2nd half of the match is mainly a Show fighting Test so they can set up that incredible spot.***"
[10.0] "Is this a good match on any technical level? NO! Is this a super entertaining match featuring a Hall of Fame wrestling stunt with great character work from Shane and big show (something that both lacked a lot in their careers after 2001) and a hot crowd? YES!"
[5.0] "As others have stated, its a pretty standard Shane O'Mac match, but it's fun to watch. As usual, Shane busts out some unique offense to show his desperation to get a win over an opponent that's undermining his capabilities. The elbow drop at the end is one of his most memorable daredevil endeavors."
[9.0] "Big Show is kept very strong for another Pay Per View, Shane McMahon earns his place on the car by jumping from the top of the world and this match doesn't dissapoint. It plays fantastically on the ongoing angle with Test entering and all that, the pace doesn't miss a bit and it serves as a great example of an 'all over the arena' match."
[4.0] "Like many Shane McMahon matches, it's a slow walk to the big spot. It's not that bad but I didn't find it too thrilling, even with the big fall."
[4.0] "I really didn't enoyed the match at all. It was slow and almost nothing happened for 10 minutes. The final spot is awesome and deserving 4 points, but there's nothing more to this match."
[6.0] "A standard match for Shane O Mack with the use of foreign objects and a tougher match style. Big Show could have finished the match several times, but he, like a beast, wanted to completely destroy the opponent, fortunately Shane was not prevented by the intervention from Vince and Test arrived in time and saved him. But of course, the main action was a crazy and great jump from a great height."
[6.0] "This was an average Shane McMahon match, in that it was mostly based around simple pro wrestling maneuvers and spots. As a last man standing match this was okay but nothing great, pretty forgettable except for Shane McMahon jumping off of the stage set at the end"
