[6.0] "A fine match, great charcter work with all the screams from Chuck Taylor, which remainded funny some how. Gargano was great and looked RIPPED! Solid start, solid mid and solid ending to the match. Loved that the crowd made a small botch from Taylor and Gargano work with a "you killed Johnny""
[6.0] "This was fairly decent, but largely just the pretty typical indy match between two guys who are friends. There were a couple of spots that acknowledged the familiarity between the two, and a relatively light hearted tone - probably a little bit too cheesy for me, if I'm being honest. The biggest moment was the botched spot where Taylor completely missed the apron with a release suplex, sending Gargano crashing to the floor instead. It didn't really factor into the match much at all, though, as they quickly moved back on to what they had planned instead of improvising and building off what was a painful looking move. Nothing all that memorable, really."
[7.0] "Fairly good match, with especially fluid movements that made it go smoothly and feel shorter than it was, doing the job without overstaying its welcome, just a pleasing good time."
[7.0] "It's been a few years since I watched this match. I have it rated *** 3/4 in my notes. It was quite good, with Gargano standing out in particular."