| 1 | 10.12.2025 | boymeetsworld | 7.0 | First half of this match did a good job building up anticipation for a hot finishing stretch, especially because their chemistry was surprisingly great. Second half saw one of the best performances from Candice outside of PWG that I can remember, plus Gargano was excellent and making her look as good as possible, last few minutes were really good. |
| 2 | 09.12.2025 | PapaGus | 9.0 | Excellent intergender match, which is no surprise given their chemistry was almost guaranteed to be good. |
| 3 | 05.01.2025 | The Joseph | 8.0 | A few spots at the very beginning felt a little mistimed, but after that this match was great. Candice and Johnny obviously have great chemistry and told the perfect story for an intergender match. |
| 4 | 06.10.2022 | Bluelegend20 | 8.0 | One of the best intergender matches I've watched. It was competitive and Candice was treated seriously. The counters were great and the action was good. |
| 5 | 08.09.2020 | Wrestling Forever | 8.0 | Erste Match der lange Fehde von Candice vs Johnny bei AIW. Richtig starkes Ding da war es egal wenn sie damals schon in einer Beziehung standen. 2014 habe ich gedacht Candice ist mit Joey zusammen. Klasse Match (***1/2). |
#