[6.0] "Whats not to like i mean this was amazing as it happened. Sid was over i remember i was hyped that sid was in ecw. Seeing him just crush everyone was something worth seeing. In hindsight Sid wasn't there for long but had an impact. As for this "impromptu" match/segment it was decent with the anticipation of what was to come. Barely any wrestling but Sid dropping the stretcher after he fully extends over his head on d-von is highlight. What a time it was to be a fan"
[4.0] "They definitely had something with Sid here, but the execution was off. He should have immediately destroyed The Dudleys, yet instead he started selling for no reason, which killed some of the momentum. Because of that, the pop for the Powerbomb wasn't nearly as big as it could have been. Not really a match, more of an angle - but one that could have been pulled off much better."
[2.0] "It's meant to be Nova & Spike, but the Dudleys take Nova out before things really get going. They stop and do a promo, eventually Sid comes out and doesn't really do much, but it's Sid so the crowd pops anyway. Not very interesting, Bubba and Spike did a few fun spots together."
[1.0] "Spike getting thrown into the crowd: they've done it before Sid getting a huge pop for existing: each week he's on TV The Dudley's telling the crowd they suck but since it's pay per view they can use unbleeped F words. Not for me"
[2.0] "Hard match to rate... if you can even call it a match really? so the Dudley Boyz have been continuing their rampage and taking out various talent and call out out anybody to answer their open challenge - which Spike & Nova do. But what follows is basically a tag team squash match, with Spike being launched into the crowd and away from the action for a while, and Nova? ...well, I'm not sure what happened to him. So after demolishing those 2, The Dudleyz again call out someone to face them. This time Sid (who the crowd had been chanting for during Steve Corino's in-ring promo time earlier) answers their call and destroys them and eventually also Spike - who'd found his way back into the ring to score a victory. So basically there's a lot of stuff that happens here, but not enough continuous wrestling action for me, more of a drawn-out angle."
[4.0] "This is a bit difficult to rate, because as a wrestling match it's fairly poor, but as an angle it's a lot of fun. Spike getting thrown in to the crowd, Sid's surprise appearance, a stretcher getting dropped on D-Von, some cool looking powerbombs (especially that final one after the match) - it's hard not to have fun with this. A lot of the execution outside of those spots is very weak, but for pure entertainment value this was still worth watching."
[3.0] "Well, coming out after New Jack is one way to pretend Sid has some talent, and while this was also nonsense that was only barely wrestling-adjacent it was at least vaguely entertaining, it was rare that the Dudley's completely failed. Still nowhere near being actually good, though."
[4.0] "Really more of an angle than a match, but an entertaining one and a perfect usage of Sid. The Dudley Boyz claim they've taken out everyone and there's no one left for them to fight, so out comes Sid to face them down. Sid doesn't really do much, but the crowd popped huge anyway. Can't really give this a higher rating since it wasn't much of a match, but it's a segment worth watching."