[1.0] "1 points for all the beautiful women in ring. I'm glad the divas era died. That entire promo package was just them flaunting on how grateful they for being a diva and talked about everything but wrestling."
[3.0] "Other than Maria Menounus who has literally no business in the match and then pinning Beth Phoenix to win, the in ring action from other three ladies are not bad by any means. I liked several moves from Kelly Kelly, it looked good tbh. Overall I feel it is literally waste of those three ladies, which should have a triple threat for the divas title instead. This match, 10-Divas Tag where Vickie Guerrero picked a messy win, and Mixed tag in Mania 27 where Snooki pinning McCool are really telling how much they actuallly really cared women's wrestling at that time. [*1/2]"
[0.0] "What was the point here? Maria isn't a Hollywood celebrity to put over, she is just a news anchor. Why is Beth pheonix and Eve Torres wasted to put her over? Why does this match exist? It's simply a waste of the spot and time"
[0.0] "This was pointless. Beth Phoenix was made to look weak, Maria Menounos should not have been in that position, and nothing about this felt like it belonged on WrestleMania. It was slow, awkward, and completely forgettable. Not even a decent moment to save it. Just pure filler."
[1.0] "1 point for Beth Phoenix who deserved so much better in her career. She was so far beyond the skills of the other 3 that it was frustrating to watch. Absolute dog shit match."
[2.0] "The Divas Champion getting pinned by the celeb guest should tell you everything about how WWE felt about their women's division at the time. The match itself was fine enough for what it was and covered the limitations of Menounos."
[2.0] "What the hell was this? They seriously couldn't come up with anything better than this for the Women's Champion? Maria Menounos is at least a likeable personality, but is she really a big enough celebrity for this position? And don't even get me started on the fact that she gets the fall over Beth Phoenix of all people... The actual wrestling isn't horrendous considering who is involved (but it's still a far way from being good), but the booking is offensive enough that a failing grade definitely feels warranted."
[0.0] "This was ridiculously bad and even a waste of 5 minutes in the show where they could've used it elsewhere - beth getting pinned by a celebrity was a poor booking decision aswell considering she was the champion at the time and the standout in a poor divison"
[3.0] "I surely have a problem with Beth being pinned by WHO? But anyway, this match was bad even before the start, awful. What surprised me was Kelly Kelly's move, because of which I raise the vote to 3. Beyond that, it's not a match worthy for the most important wrestling event in the world. And why in the blue hell did it last more than 6 minutes (and more of the IC Title match)?"
[3.0] "A pretty lackluster match although I was pretty impressed with Kelly Kelly's Molly-Go-Round near the middle. Beth getting pinned by a television personality isn't my favorite thing either and didn't do much to get anyone over. 2 stars."
[0.0] "Just another really bad women's match that shouldn't even be on a WrestleMania, Maria Menounos was just bad in this match, Kelly wasnt good either and having them beat Phoenix and Eve made those two look weak. Awful tag match between both teams and shouldnt have been on a WrestleMania."
[3.0] "While this match wasn't horrendous, it is a far cry away from being Wrestlemania worthy. The majority of the match is very weak looking and sloppy offense that isn't going to convince anyone. Kelly Kelly has one solid spot that brings one thing of note to this otherwise bad match. There's really nothing to see here. It's a boring and sloppy match that is, at no point, entertaining."
[2.0] "I feel weird for saying that Maria Menonous had a better Mania match than Victoria and Molly Holly here, but working with Beth and Eve certainly helps. Both were able to carry the other team, though they really couldn't do much. It wasnt good, but it felt like I was watching Misawa & Kobashi vs. Taue & Kawada compared to almost every prior Divas WrestleMania matches."
[0.0] "Having Beth Phoenix losing against a celebrity who can't wrestle at Wrestlemania should show you how the divas were treated like a joke back then. dud"
[2.0] "I thought Eve Torres was generally alright. Maybe even a bit underrated. And Maria Menounos always came across as likeable and genuinely interested in WWE in her appearances. This match was not good though. Not good at all. No place on a Wrestlemania card if we're being honest."
[1.0] "Das war ja mal absolut gar nichts! Nichtmal Beth Phoenix konnte das Match hier nach oben ziehen. Stellenweise habe ich mir sorgen um die Gesundheit der Workerinnen gemacht. Wenigstens war es nicht peinlich?"
[3.0] "Jerry Lawler is still in perv mode, despite us being 5 years into the PG era at this point. I always remember Eve Torres as the workhorse of the PG Diva's era. She wouldn't get much to work with, but she always put in the effort to get something decent of any situation. Beth Phoenix and her are calling the match, which is good as their opponents are a non-wrestler in Maria Menounos and Kelly Kelly. To Kelly's credit, she didn't do anything to harm this match. She hit her flying head scissors and even a somersault seated senton from the top rope. This wasn't a good match, but it was too short to be anything too offensive. Menounos had cracked ribs here and still wanted to do the match, so props to her."
[2.0] "Beth Phoenix schafft es, mit Kelly Kelly hier zwei solide Sequenzen zu worken, aber letztendlich reicht das nicht, um ein ausreichendes Match vor zehntausenden Fans bei WrestleMania zu bieten, denn das waren die einzigen zwei soliden Sequenzen im ganzen Match. Diese Ära des Divenwrestling finde ich einfach nur schade, wenn man bedenkt, was Phoenix, Kim, James und co für tolle Mania Matches haben können mit dem Talent Pool von heute. Dieses Match steht für die Ära irgendwo stellvertretend."
[0.0] "I don't hate this era of women's wrestling or these particular wrestlers the way some do, but I do have to say I think this was really crap. I never saw much value in Eve, and while Kelly isn't *quite* as bad as she's made out, she's far from good. A random "celebrity" and an underused Beth Phoenix... yeah, skip this for sure."
[4.0] "Torres and Phoenix looked alright in this match but this match was pretty forgettable plus Kelly Kelly was involved in this match, that said this wasn't Kelly Kelly's worst match"
