[6.0] "Extremely overhated match. Yes, it was not the greatest we've seen from Willow because Kamille was a bit of a clunky opponent, but I liked the arm work pretty well and just frankly didn't think it was that bad at all."
[3.0] "Lol, this got more time than some matches at WM. This did not need or deserve even the time it did get. Why do we have someone like Camille on TV when there are plenty of better, more talented woman that deserve the time."
[3.0] "Yea this was a tough watch. I kinda just felt bad for everyone involved. I felt bad for Willow Nightingale having to sell for this green ass wrestler. I felt bad for the commentary team having to put Kamille over as a dominant force. I felt bad for Kamille for being put in a position she isn't ready for. I felt bad for the women who don't get tv time while we're all subjected to this. Willow sells the arm incredibly and that's about as much positivity I have towards the match. Kamille has no presence. She sells like she's drunk almost immediately. She's got no intensity whatsoever. It's tough coming back from injury after over a year and even harder when you were never great in the first place. AEW has Megan Bayne and Lena Kross now and I don't see how Kamille can effectively fit into the division as it stands today"
[2.0] "[1.0*] Kamille is someone who will create drama when she's not being used. She'll also say some of the stupidest things ever and it will be bad for your company. She's also a horrible wrestler. I don't know why Tony brought her back. Probably the worst AEW signing ever."
[6.0] "I can't find all the rottenness that most people saw in it. Is it a good match? No, but it's not bad either, especially considering it's a TV match. Willow does well in elevating Kamille, and however forgettable this may be, it doesn't offend me [***]."
[2.0] "Who asked for Kamille to come back? She looked very slow here and there was maybe one move she did that looked solid enough. This was short, and I don't like that Willow won via backslide considering there's a good chance that this feud continues. You have Athena stuck in ROH yet Kamille gets this opportunity? Hilarious."
[3.0] "This match was underwhelming because of Kamille. Willow Nightingale did her thing, but Kamille is just not good at this wrestling thing. But Willow Nightingale got the win and retained her AEW TBS Title, but I hope this is the end of that quick feud with Kamille, and going on to better pastures."
[3.0] "Kamille completely lacks both personality and in-ring ability here, which is a shame given that we know she is capable of more. Despite being presented as this powerful monster, she looks limp in offence and sells poorly in defence. Willow put in a bang-average showing as well. Hopefully we move on from this as soon as possible."
[3.0] "Kamille is back on TV for some reason and idk why because she's fucking terrible. Willow tries her hardest in this match but Kamille is just so shit. Horrifically dull control work as well as some embarrassingly bad bumping for Willow's offence. I really do not understand the booking of the women's division. There's so many talented wrestlers on the roster yet TK constantly gives TV time to shitters like Kamille instead of people who are actually good. Bizarre. *3/4"
[3.0] "This rating solely reflects Kamille, and her dogshit performance. She's been away for a year and a half, and she is somehow worse than she was from where she left off. It's crystal clear that she does not care at all to improve in the ring whatsoever. She literally could not be bothered to at least move well in the ring. Instead, we were left with her very low mobility, low effort, and low in ring IQ as she literally seemed like she was freestyling every maneuver with no rhyme or reason. She could not even at least jump a decent height to sell the pounce. My god is she awful. Thankfully, the direction seems to be Willow/Shida next, which means this is probably a one and done for Kamille. I'm only giving this a 3 for willow's great performance as always."
[4.0] "Oh my poor Willow i am so sorry you had to have this match. I can't even blame her for not seeming to turn in one of her normal performances to carry a lesser opponent to a good match because why would she be interested in this shit storyline. Like we could of had her open challenge on the PPV be answered by any one like Athena or Billie but no we get this Shit with Kamille. God she is even worse than i remember her being back in 2024 god Christ this was a rough watch. She just has nothing good about her to the point she is the worst type of wrestler one that is so bad you just don't care. God lets just move on from this and get Willow some better matches in the next few weeks please. Also can we stop having Willow win with the backslide so often man it is so stupid she is a powerhouse let her hit the babe with the powerbomb ffs. (**)"
[3.0] "I'm not sure what this was or who put this match together but can we please get Willow out of the trenches. Kamille is a poor wrestler who hasn't wrestled in absolutely ages and ahs no business immediately challenging an actual worker for a title, let alone Willow. Terrible execution all round."
[2.0] "[2.4] Yeah no this was awful and it's entirely on Kamille. She's somehow gotten worse than she was in 2024 and had already been completely lapped in her own role by like half a dozen other women. Willow tried to pull off the carry, but this was just not good. You can only do so much with someone so slow, untalented low-effort, and heatless, and it was just a drag. The fact that the ending protected Kamille which means that there could be more of her instead of the other infinitely more talented women who don't get booked sucked too. I know she's against it, but it would be of great benefit to us all if she just aborted her career."
[3.0] "Willow tried. That's really the best thing I have to say about this match, which was the lowlight on an otherwise really strong Dynamite. There's just too many talented women on the roster to be putting this on TV."
[4.0] "My complaint about this match was the minimal build. Felt like after the PPV attack it could've been something more, even if the match itself would probably still under deliver. But I thought the match was ok. It doens't help that Kamille lacks the charisma of big women like Bayne."
[6.0] "Kamille isn't the most flamboyant wrestler, but I found her performance decent within her style. Willow managed another victory with a cunning pinfall, though she wasn't particularly impressive throughout the match. The bout at least had a purpose and something at stake, which is refreshing in this often-neglected women's division. In-ring quality: 1/4. Stakes: 1.5/2. Justification: 1/1. Card placement: 1/1. Suspense: 0.25/1. Bonus/penalty: None. Total: 5.75/10. Match watched on MyAEW."
[5.0] "Hotshotting Kamille into a title match after a pre-show match following her being benched in AEW since October 2024 was certainly a choice. Not a bad match but one that felt like a disservice to both wrestlers with making it a bigger deal. An underwhelming ending did not do them any favors."
[4.0] "I'm sorry Willow, but good lord all mighy Kamille, I had high hopes for you at one point, but you gave us literally less than nothing here, where is anything, where is the HOSS power, she looked dreadful in the ring, dreadful stuff, Willow did her best."
[5.0] "I'm struggling to understand why the response to this match has been so negative. The match was no classic but the work was solid. Kamille didn't look remotely out of place."
"I didn't get why they put her on this spot, without a bit of getting free on the ring in front of people once again. There is not so much to say, Willow great as always."
[4.0] "Yeah, this was rough... I feel bad for Kamille though, I think having been out for such a long time, that she is probably a little rusty. I am not sure what the point of this match was and it risked damaging Kamille's return when she should probably be booked to appear strong and imposing. I didn't hate the match, but it certainly wasn't great. I am not sure why they brought Kamille back (no disrespect to her), but I hope for her sake they have a plan for her."
[3.0] "This is just awful. The TBS Championship situation frustrates me every week, but tonight was the culmination of a nightmare. It was a completely boring and unremarkable match that ended in a defensive manner, which makes me think this story is far from over, and we're in for another match between them."
[4.0] "People will crash out about the Darby title win until the cows come home, but the return of Kamille is the bigger headscratcher for me. Like, she may have shone in the NWA, but that's more an indictment on the NWA than it is a compliment to her skills. She's just not good, at all, and I would've preferred her to seek matches elsewhere before returning to AEW television. But it is what is. Kudos to Willow for managing to make this not the worst match in the world, but it's the least good match I've seen in Dynamite in quite a while."
[3.0] "Pretty boring nothing match. Willow certainly tried her best here but Kamille is just a super uninteresting wrestler to watch (based on her AEW run at least). There's worse stuff, but Kamille looked pretty awful here and I definitely wasn't entertained watching this one. Way below Willow's caliber of match."
[0.0] "That was straight up hot garbage. Can't even find any redeeming quality. No chemistry, no heat and an absolute waste of time even if it was 8 minutes. I don't find Willow all that good in the ring because of her clunky work but can't even blame her here. Kamille is really terrible, wrestling an actual broomstick would provide better results. At least an impactul finish with Kamille getting powerbombed would have salvaged this but a lame roll up ending was befitting of this mess."
[4.0] "Give Willow her flowers for selling so well that Kamille's awful heat segment looked effective despite not even getting a simple wrenching of the arm correct. Willow's comebacks are always great too and mostly on her to make them look good, though Kamille took what might be the worst Pounce bump I've ever seen. Willow struggling to hit her finish due to her arm and Kamille being a larger opponent gave the final stretch a bit of drama before she won another way. Monumental carry job and it was still below-average, get Kamille the hell out of this company. **1/4"
[3.0] "Kamille is awful, struggles to connect on any of her moves and moves slower than all hell. No idea why they thought bringing her back was a good idea. Willow tried to pull something out with the selling of her arm, but even she can't carry someone so bad."
0x
0x
0x
0x
3x
37x
56x
59x
10x
0x
1x