[9.0] "A genuinely underrated match in AEW. A very good street fight with Toa Liona having the most show-out moments in the match. In the original broadcast, this was the last match that aired before a technical error ended the show prematurely to air Black Adam. To me, this is still the main event of this Collision."
[7.0] "The best match of the show, in my opinion. It's a little surprising to me, as I'm not the biggest fan of most of the people in this match. I really like Keith, but Bill and The Gates of Agony are just solid to me. That said, this was a pretty fun time overall."
[9.0] "Since they showed up in AEW, I have not ben the biggest fans of the Gates of Agony. Despite showing potential, they have been rather dull. They looked quite good in this one through, and Bill and Keith once again show that they have developed surprisingly strong chemistry. Some very nice no DQ spots here as well, very enjoyable."
[9.0] "Not sure how this isn't rated higher..... this was so awesome. I loved the way they used different weapons then normal like Sheetrock, street signs, cones etc. Both of these teams are unbelievably underrated. ****1/4"
[6.0] "It's not because this match stood out in a bad show that there is something special here, here it is simply the most standard and uninspired street fight possible, the only highlight worth commenting on is the performance of Toa Liona who really plays the role of unstoppable monster very well. [***1/4]"
[8.0] "Random AEW TV feuds turning into awesome Hardcore brawls is one of my favorite things and this was no exception, but not a surprise given the fun brawl these teams had to set it up. Gates of Agony have been getting a bigger spot in the tag division lately and it's really great to see Bill & BK spread their wings without being tied to an aging Jericho. Bill & Liona were the stars here, just big men crashing into each other and beating down their respective partners, while Kaun played up his "hurt me more" shtick that I've been liking and Bryan slotted into his spots well during brawling and when GoA needed to ragdoll someone. Liona also showed a lot more personality here than I've ever seen out of him, playing to the crowd without going full babyface and just looking bemused when BK tried to hurt a Samoan by hitting him on the forehead. Loved that Bill just brought a backpack full of bricks to a street fight too. Solid, definitive finishing sequence that made both teams look good as well. ****"
[8.0] "Once these Gates of Agony guys come into their own with confidence in their presentation, the whole thing is gonna click in a cool way. Plus, someone get them a new name--sounds so much like "Authors of Pain" and is equally cringe. Love Schiavone coming back from commercial: "This Chicago street fight continues on TNT, that is Brian Keith in the trashcan! " Great physical exchanges between Big BIll and the Gates outside the ring. This match is deconstructing the ringside infrastructure with every move. In this match, you get a piece of drywall, bricks, tables, trashcans and just about everything else get used. Bishop Kaun takes the pin after a thunderous chokeslam, but he showed some cool personality here, laughing ironically like a madman when you think he'd be in pain. This felt like a positive bloodbath for both teams."
[7.0] "Fun plunder match to spruce up a fairly average Collision. Big Bill and Bryan Keith are slowly building a case towards a future challenge for the Tag Team Titles, and the Gates of Agony were good foils here."
[7.0] "This really over-delivered for me not gonna lie. Not the craziest or bloodiest street fight AEW's ever had but I feel like a lot of the plunder spots had a good weight to them and everyone took some gnarly bumps here."