[6.0] "Surprisingly one of the better matches on this show. Cargill has shown signs of improvement, and I think this was a nice example of that. She's still far from putting on the best matches, but this was one of her more enjoyable matches, at least for me."
"I will just point out that this is one of Jade's best matches because of formula and WWE. In AEW, there was no flow to any of what she was doing and they got by on her doing crazy stuff. This was slow and not notable, outside of the hot crowd cheering Jade's traditional comeback. And they cheered because of the formula. She did not have that and would have never had that in AEW. Crowd was even able to muster that noise for her comeback after acting like they wanted Zelina Vega, of all people, to do the same in a longer match before that."
[5.0] "Although the match certainly doesn't leave anything to be desired, it's probably the best that Jade Cargill has had in the WWE to date. And a lot of that is down to Liv Morgan, who now knows exactly what she can do and how she can influence with her facial expressions. It's solid work and a passable match. I mean, hey, Cargill's still in it."
[3.0] "This was not a good match. Liv was okay but Cargill was painfully bad here. She looked completely stiff and unmotivated. She's just not a good worker and has continually proved this already. Liv's spots are the only thing from making this match a complete throwaway"
[8.0] "This was a great match, you can definitely tell that Liv Morgan has the better in-ring abilities and had to carry throughout this match. Jade did do very well at covering for her lacking of in-ring skills and overall this was definitely match of the night for me."
[5.0] "**.75 Liv carried the hell out of Jade in this match, although it does look as though Jade is slowly but surely improving, hopefully she finds some steady progress. Liv is just at the top of her game right now, best she's looked throughout her career"
[8.0] "This Match is just Fantastic, im sorry but Liv Morgan, really hasn't had a bad match AT ALL in 2025 so far, and has had bangers with literally everyone, and im sorry happy she is. This win was unexpected but this furthers the feud with Naomi, and im all in for this, but my only problem is Liv is basically being the launcher for Wrestlemania storylines, like how she was last year, and even Now, with Rhea vs IYO, and Now Naomi vs Jade, i just wish she gets a feud or storyline that's good, because she really deserves it."
[6.0] "Liv Morgan's hot streak continues, leading Jade Cargill to possibly her best WWE performance yet. In fairness, Cargill isn't some broomstick here either, clearly working hard and bumping with visible intent. **3/4"
[7.0] "This was Jade Cargill's best singles match in WWE. Liv Morgan Man has been the MVP for the women in WWE and has been one of the better female wrestlers in the world today. They had very solid chemistry in this match. I thought Jade Cargill made a lot of improvement it was very evident in this match. Also, thanks to Naomi, Jade Cargill suffered her first singles loss in WWE as she lost to Liv Morgan. This match was really fun, one of the better matches from this show tonight. It was great stuff by both ladies."
[6.0] "It was... Average? Idk why some people are hyping it like it was Punk Vs Drew at Bad Blood, Liv was just okay, Jade is still not good, and the result was wrong"
[4.0] "This was no five star classic and I'm a bit bewildered it's rated sol highly. While Jade has improved there was still plenty of sloppy offence to go around from both participants. The sloppy booking also got its moment as well with Naomi rocking up in the end. I'm dreading the mania match. Booking Jade to lose and look like a clown while doing so is certainly a choice."
"(8.0 )Match of the night Liv did amazing as she's done done all of 2025 I don't give a damn what y'all say and Jade looked good I also liked Naomi coming out there hitting Jade with the title"
[6.0] "This was a solid match. Before Naomi got involved I thought the two had good chemistry and it was an enjoyable matchup. Finish was obviously looking to give Liv the win while keeping Jade looking strong."
[4.0] "Waaaaaaay to long. This match had nothing to do with the Cargill-Naomi story and only at the end Naomi showed up to cost Jade the match. Boring feud with boring build, this match should habe been 5 minutes. Overall very bad show and boring this mania build has been really disappointing so far. Cena only showed on 2 Raws this year and he challenges Cody Rhodes who is smackdown's champion but he is not scheduled to show once on smackdown that is absolutely crazy. Instead of Cena/Rock/Cody promos we get this crap"
[6.0] "It was a decent match, Liv and Jade both looked good. I thought Liv winning was the wrong choice, and they could have a better finish. I am interested in What is next in Jade and Naomi's feud"
[7.0] "I thought this was solid. its the most comfortable ive seen Jade in wwe.jade taking the pin was a shock but I loved it and it made sense! heel Naomi is gonna be fun going into wrestle mania against Jade"
[7.0] "I thought this was a really solid match between both women here. Liv Morgan is such a workhorse, and she's REALLY underrated in the ring; especially since she's low-key been giving awesome performances in her matches in 2025 so far. Plus, this match should prove that Jade Cargill is FULLY capable of delivering a solid singles match that lasts longer than 7 minutes. Additionally, BIG kudos to Jade Cargill for properly putting someone over (aka Liv Morgan) here. Bianca Belair should take notes. She needs to learn how to freaking lose to a pinfall finisher instead of losing to these stupid lame fluke rollups. Anyway, Liv vs Jade gets a solid 6.5 out of 10 here; but I am leaning more toward a 7 here."
[5.0] "Jade Cargill vs. Liv Morgan, Jade Gargill war das einzige, was dieses Match solide und guckbar gemacht hat. Liv Morgan ist keine sehr gute Wrestlerin. Würde sie nicht so aussehen wie aussieht, wäre sie niemand. 2.75*"
[5.0] "Best match of the night until that point, as expected, Liv is in a very good moment, and Jade despite not being particularly the most technical and smooth wrestler, she's very intriguing and can get the audience going, so this was quite nice, a charismatic match. Jade suffered a very rare pinfall loss, after ANOTHER dirty finish, where Naomi appeared and distracted her. Despite the lame finish, the match was alright, Liv got great reactions in her moves like always - {**1/4}"
