[7.0] "This was a strong send-off match for Josh Alexander against one of his best & formidable opponents, Eric Young. The story was simple and to the point - betrayal! That was more than enough to set up a quick grudge match, and their chemistry that was developed for a while helped it to be better than anticipated. However, it wasn't as sensational as their match at Slammiversary '22. Even though the finish didn't sit well considering Josh's status quo, it fits the story of EY leading Sinner & Saint in his diabolical way. 3.5 out of 5 stars!"
[5.0] "Mediocre match, the action was not up to par. Plus, it was all made worse by the fact that this was Alexander's last match in TNA. The only positive for this is Eric Young's win, which will help him solidify his new heel image."
[7.0] "A good match to end Josh Alexander's great run in TNA on against someone who he has shown to have good chemistry with over the last few years in Eric Young. While it didn't hit the highs of their best match together at Slammiversary 2022, it was a good match between them. Losing Josh is a pretty heavy blow to TNA and hopefully they are able to find ways to make up for his absence."
[6.0] "Pretty solid match. The best of the night. My biggest problem is Alexander losing. He is the Standard of TNA for a reason and this as his last match just felt off. Not saying that Young was the wrong opponent, it just felt very rushed."