DeutschEnglish
You are on the public version of the site. | Log In | Register | Password lost?
CAGEMATCH » Matches » Marina Shafir vs. Mina Shirakawa » Ratings

Marina Shafir vs. Mina Shirakawa

Match

Displaying items 1 to 100 of total 101 items that match the search parameters.
1
2
>
>|
#DateUserRatingComment
120.03.2026GGWITT5.0 
220.03.2026Ozwern6.0Last minute replacement for Toni who seems to be out for a long time which sucks so bad, division will be in hell without her. Mina did well considering circumstances and outside of the awful table spot, nothing atrocious happened. Decent match.
320.03.2026Morbino456.0 
420.03.2026deanepuddle7.0 
520.03.2026HC76.0 
620.03.2026ProjektCloudz6.0This match on paper should've never worked, and in many ways it didn't. It's a no holds barred match that feels more like a throwaway no DQ match. Despite that, Marina is still improving and this match showcased how far she's come as a solo talent. Mina can make any match fun and that's exactly what she did here, albeit to mixed results. That table spot dragged it down a bit for me though, I got Nia Jax flashbacks seeing how awkward Mina's head hit the floor. A solid match if nothing else.
720.03.2026Willie 192007.0 
820.03.2026SkyIcons6.0This was weird, not even particularly bad, I enjoyed it, but something felt off. Crowd was dead silent most of the time as well. Mina winning was a nice surprise.
920.03.2026urrklz8786.0 
1020.03.2026kacy noah4.0I'm glad Mina got a win under her belt, but this was meh. For what's supposed to be a No Holds Barred match, they don't really spend a lot of time taking advantage of the stipulation. That botched table spot was extremely worrying.
1120.03.2026Wrestling Forever 7.0Inzwischen ist bekannt das Toni Real Life verletzt ist und lange ausfällt. Das ist echt bitter für Mina und die Women Division. Wer Toni attackiert hat ist unbekannt. Es war ein gutes No Holds Barred Match dem ich ein Match Rating von (***) gebe.
1220.03.2026King of Strong Style6.0 
1320.03.2026Touch6doen75.0 
1420.03.2026Marcelvar7.0Schönes Hardcore Match. Mochte das Detail mit den Champagner Flaschen. Das hat gut gepasst. Ich denke 7 Punkte sind angemessen.
1520.03.2026greatchickendoc6.0 
1620.03.2026VINCEoWrestling5.0 
1720.03.2026R98.0 
1820.03.2026DammitChrist7.0 
1920.03.2026Luj5.0 
2020.03.2026Edge6.0 
2120.03.2026Kenney59166.0 
2220.03.2026m19995.0 
2320.03.2026zags70006.0 
2420.03.2026NOCIVE7.0 
2520.03.2026Dcarter11536.0 
2620.03.2026Jon Hetrick6.0 
2720.03.2026saysthemark7.0 
2820.03.2026JGM5.0 
2920.03.2026jaletta7.0Mina gets a win! I think this was a decent amount above average. Mina as a singles performer has been generally a miss from me despite enjoying her character, and Mina has been really improving in how much she seems to invest in her matches emotionally. Good stuff.
3020.03.2026WJA19896.0 
3120.03.2026Nard1907.0 
3220.03.2026mateofuerte6.0 
3319.03.2026Porcelain85.0 
3419.03.2026KingChook5.0 
3519.03.2026EmoForkliftDriver5.0I don't think either woman is capable of pulling the other to a good match even with the short cuts of a no holds barred match. Marina Shafir's heelish drinking of the champagne was fun and Mina Shirakawa's natural Babyface fire was good but the ring work was sloppy and the big spots were ok. The table spot was awkward because yes landing on the floor is worse in shoot but in kayfabe it looks like Shafir does more damage to herself. Interesting giving Shirakawa' the win but I'm at least intrigued to see what comes next now
3619.03.2026YB25.0 
3719.03.2026MrWeen8.0This gets an extra point for the outcome. This made Mina look really strong. This win will do her good and will help other people get over that she loses to. Good to see the Mina that I really liked in Japan.
3819.03.2026PerceptionIsReality5.0 
3919.03.2026Personano6.0 
4019.03.2026Guddi6.0 
4119.03.2026ZooWee7.0I thought this ruled. Marina is slowly becoming one of my favourites to watch in AEW. You can tell she's been training under Mox because a lot of her control work here is very Mox-esque with the way she carries herself and viciously wears down Mina in this match. Im not usually a big Mina fan but outside of a few weak looking weapon shots, she was good here. I loved how scrappy her offence was as it felt like she was trying to survive Marina. Some cool spots in this too, most notably that brutal looking table spot on the outside. It sucks that Toni got pulled out of this one last minute and i do think this wouldve been better with her in it but overall, this was still very good regardless and the best match on this show without a doubt. ***3/4
4219.03.2026nylonmascots7.0 
4319.03.2026homunculus7.0 
4419.03.2026SmartForceOne7.0 
4519.03.20262185.0 
4619.03.2026robbyplaha6.0Originally, it was supposed to be Toni Storm, but she was KO'd backstage as blood poured through her skull, and Mina Shirakawa filled in for her. I was fine with the pivot as I'm a fan of Mina Shirakawa, but it leads me to believe she was the one who did that to Toni Storm. Maybe in due time, we'll figure out who took out Toni Dtorm. But this match was fine. Marnia Shafir, with back-to-back matches of her having a passable performance, I'm not a fan of her as a performer. She isn't good in the ring; the only thing I remember about her is that awful promo she did years back. But the ending to this match was cool, and glad Mina Shirakawa got the win.
4719.03.2026Screensquatteur6.0 
4819.03.2026Nulltarif3.0Das war größtenteils einfach nur langweilig. Wenig aus der no holds barred Stipulation rausgeholt und der Tischspot ist gehörig daneben gegangen. Das Mina hier gewinnt, war eine Überraschung. Dennoch hätte ich mir hier eine dominante Shafir eher gewünscht (* 3/4)
4919.03.2026AJ Styles was better than your favorite [4.0] I had absolutely zero interest in this match. Marina has been feuding with Toni and Mina for as long as I can remember. The match she had with Toni at revolution was billed as the "last one". So why is this happening? Whether Toni is actually hurt or not, this shouldn't be happening dude. The match itself wasn't even good. Marina could've seriously hurt Mina with that table spot and it's not the first time something like this has happened with her. The only positive takeaway here is that Mina won, and I can't believe she's even in a situation like this in the first place.
5019.03.2026kitoruby6.0 
5119.03.2026Ariak7.0 
5219.03.2026bnummer6.0 
5319.03.2026vacho [6.5] It was going well but the finish was really weird. The table spot was brutal, mina seems fine afterwards so i'm glad. I just hope they let Marina be now.
5419.03.2026LuminousPink [6] Cool to see Mina not only in a match but also getting a win! Decent little match too, just a good bit of fun tbh.
5519.03.2026Chad7227.0 
5619.03.2026Connor266.0 
5719.03.2026ParkwayDriver6.0 
5819.03.2026Mihaawk6.0 
5919.03.2026weez5.0 
6019.03.2026soba5.0 
6119.03.2026Sky2276.0 
6219.03.2026JediSaiyanMaster12036.0 
6319.03.2026Trombek Kushinika5.0 
6419.03.2026Contrasoma5.0 
6519.03.2026eltetechori6.0This match was actually pretty decent in terms of the stipulation, though the storyline didn't really grab my attention, it just isn't my thing. It was decent and even funny, and I wasn't expecting much, but hey, it was good at times.
6619.03.2026wingedeagle8.0 
6719.03.20268JsStyles6.0 
6819.03.2026NoMoreBS Glizzy8.0I LOVED this match, just good tv bollocks, a late sub out for a legitmately injured Toni isn't ideal when it's up against the green marina shafir, but Mina and Marina did more than enough to make up for it, Marina is still green as grass but her kicks and strikes make up for alot of it, and Mina finally getting a TV win ruled, GREAT stuff, very fun TV wrestling.
6919.03.2026Kennel7.0 
7019.03.2026Immortan Scott7.0 
7119.03.2026Frenchmaker7.0 
7219.03.2026DumbleJ6.0 
7319.03.2026xenosora26.0 
7419.03.2026ColdSpoons5.0 
7519.03.2026LadySnowblood7.0 
7619.03.2026kaschi6.0 
7719.03.2026ProGraps20186.0 
7819.03.2026DXHHHHBK5.0 
7919.03.2026RyanKras166.0 
8019.03.2026IBarimani5.0 
8119.03.2026Dragon Master Adam7.0 
8219.03.2026Highbird7.0 
8319.03.2026LincolnAntoine44825.0I dug the work from Shafir for the most part here. I was a little worried because Mina is not very good and Marina is better with someone to lead her but this showed that she is really progressing in terms of putting a match together. A lot of what Mina does comes off a little too weak for me.
8419.03.2026Dawg885.0 
8519.03.2026chaqudemus6.0 
8619.03.2026MaveDeltzer4.0I didn't feel like there was much to this match outside of a few weapon spots. The table bump was okay even if it was mostly Marina going through it, which leads to one of those weird moments for commentary where they're caught between selling the table as something dangerous to be slammed through or something which protects you from the hard floor outside. The finish was okay as well but the rest of it was pretty generic hardcore match affair.
8719.03.2026AhmedHosssam238.0 
8819.03.2026conker85.0 
8919.03.2026CSTLW5.0 
9019.03.2026Rodrigo Andres7.0 
9119.03.2026casnonotbcofspn7.0Mina now! Mina wins a singles match on Dynamite for the first time in 300 days. I am overjoyed, and the match was really quite entertaining. Great finish as well.
9219.03.2026Monch Wrestling5.0 
9319.03.2026Emerald flash 337.0 
9419.03.2026Romsito6.0 
9519.03.2026Jamildo26.0This was surprisingly good. I had low expectations but both of them went for it and it was decent. The finish came off perfectly. Certainly one of the best Mina matches in a while. Just a shame that Toni was pulled. 6/10
9619.03.2026reDDragon6.0After Toni Storm was pulled from the match, I thought it would be a bust, but they found a common style right away and put on a decent show. Again, Marina Shafir thrives in matches under these rules. She's still bad in regular matches, but in a match with no restrictions, she can really put on something interesting. As a result, we got perhaps the best match of this show, which was pretty weak.
9719.03.2026richardkingsx7.0Thought this was better than I had expected. Mina getting the win was very surprising and I'm intrigued about what's next to come with the storyline on who attacked Toni
9819.03.2026Codebreaker5.0Mina Shirakawa darf tatsächlich mal was gewinnen. Match dümpelt leider so vor sich hin und die Fehde sit nach dem PPV auch kalt. **3/4
9919.03.2026Mony65  
10019.03.2026genericusername8.0Dynamite on the whole was pretty subpar but I thought this match by itself was fantastic. Had the most heat all night, a great underdog babyface performance from Mina and I think Shafir has really discovered what makes her in-ring character work. Not a huge fan of the No Holds Barred stipulation being added, because it feels like this could've just been a standard hardcore match, but this was match of the night.
1
2
>
>|
www.CAGEMATCH.net - © 2001-2026 Philip Kreikenbohm - Site Notice (German)