Madison Rayne vs. Mickie James vs. Velvet Sky vs. Winter

[3.0] "The crowd did not care about this and neither did I. The focus was more on Karen (surprise) than anything in the ring. Just a waste of time"

[2.0] "All shtick with Karen Jarrett as special referee favoring the heels being the centerpiece, rather than anything actually happening between the women. Traci Brooks eventually takes over as ref and counts the pin, which undoubtedly caused some shenanigans between her and Jarrett on Impact or whatever. Ugh. Why even have women's wrestling on your show if this is what you're going to do with it?"

[4.0] "Not really all that bad of a match but, other things to the presentation weighed it down. The crowd was NOT into this at all, and you can hear sporadic "boring" chants lasting for a number of seconds throughout this mess. I actually thought Angelina and Winter played their relationship really well here and Karen playing as a heel ref getting underneath Velvet and Mickie's skin added some drama to this. It's too bad there were other problems with this match. Velvet was not the weakest/worst part of this match. I actually that it was Madison. Madison did NOT look here at all and was off her game tonight with not selling Mickie or Velvet's offense well at all. Like Madison gave up trying here and looked bad the entire match. She made everyone else looked bad and Madison was the clear weak link here. I was more than happy Velvet became the champion but, there a few mistimed cue moments, like Madison and Mickie took a very awkward drop to the outside leaving Velvet to pick up the win on Madison. It didn't help that we didn't get to see any real cool moves like Mickie's Lou Thez Press from the top rope was missing here. The knockouts tag these girls had 2 weeks prior was a like 6.5/10 match compared to this mediocre mess. 4.25/10."

[4.0] "Not that bad of a match but being Velvet's first title, it should have felt like it Matter more than It did"

[2.0] "Some bad wrestling combined with some annoying character work from Karen Jarrett. This was supposed to be a big moment for Velvet Sky but it's hard to celebrate given how awkward most of this match felt."