[6.0] "Pretty rough show to be honest. Elgin and Roddy was fine as an opener. Lethal and Rhino was never going to be great, and it wasn't. Nana and Evan was forgettable.The street fight was pretty tame outside of the final bump where Whitmer basically piledrives himself. Lynn and Bennett was pretty decent until the poor finish (theme of the night). American Wolves V RedDragon was pretty decent and hardhitting, so that was a plus. Hardy and Cole was fairly bland and even worse another atrocious finish you'd not associate with ROH. The three way tag match was over so quickly you'd not remember anything and the main event was really good, but a poor man's version of the PWG ladder match they had, which was also overshadowed by their final Battle 2010 match. I struggled to get through this show, ROH in this era so far hasn't been much fun to watch."

[10.0] "This was an all-around fantastic Pay Per View. There were numerous great matches, which had fantastic long-term build up over the course of the past year. The matches were all solid matches, even the match between Nana and Evans. The Pay Per View as a whole is a step in the right direction for RoH."

[8.0] "Some of the booking decisions were puzzling, but there wasn't a truly bad match on the show. The Ladder War was an amazingly brutal spectacle."