[6.0] "Not an amazing show but a solid one, I would say. The crowd was having a hell of a good time. The last two matches were really great, yes including Sandman and Foley having a sick barbed wire brawl. Huge pop for Taz coming out and throwing some of the most awesome suplexes you'll ever see."
[1.0] "The first year of Extreme Championship Wrestling wasn't perfect, a lot of chaos, a lot of pros and cons, and this PPV mostly revolved around the Raven vs. Tommy Dreamer feud. Or rather, Raven and the Nest just caused chaos for most of the show. I love Raven, but it got boring fast. Most of the matches on the show weren't even matches, just beatings, but the crowd loved it. If your PPV main event has a match with Sandman, that says a lot...... Sandman sucks."
[6.0] "It started very badly with Tony Stetson VS The New Jersey Devil and Mikey Whipwreck VS Val Puccio and there was a lot of angles disguised as matches, but it ends quite good with Taz and Too Cold Scorpio VS Raven and The pitbulls and, mainly, with that surprisingly good Cactus Jack VS The Sandman. Not a great show at all but, if you like hardcore, it is still interesting to watch because of that main event."
[3.0] "Despite the last two matches the show wasnt well booked which is not a surprise looking at the card. But a lot of the card fell flat. The main event and the handicap match saved it from a lower rating."
[4.0] "This stuff was a mess. No wonder ECW went out of business. Very few actual matches and all angles dominated this card. Thankfully, it is only an hour and half on Peacock. I'm quickly fading from ECW shows and haven't ever really enjoyed them. They're for a certain breed of fan, of which I'm not."
[4.0] "Half the matches here aren't actually matches, they're very short angles, but that's better than stretching them out to be honest. The show is pretty bad overall, but is very much ECW leaning hard into what makes it ECW rather than trying to be an actual wrestling promotion. All the interesting stuff is outside of the actual wrestling, with brawls galore and the wonderful "real referee" Bill Alphonso working the crowd into a frenzy. There's no way the wrestling on this show earns it any points, but it succeeds as garbage entertainment - and that's what it was trying to be. That also makes it better than many of the WWF and WCW shows in 1995 that fail as both wrestling shows and as entertainment..."
[4.0] "Broad Street Bully vs. The New Jersey Devil war cool aber kein wirkliches Match. Mikey Whipwreck vs. Val Puccio naja nichts dolles aber sehr gute Stimmung. Hack Myers vs. The Vampire Warrior kurz aber ok. The Vampire Warrior vs. Tommy Dreamer ist ein netter Brawl. 911 vs. Jim Steele ist ein Squash Match. Beulah McGillycutty vs. Luna Vachon ist auch garkein Match und führt nur die Raven / Dreamer Fehde fort. Raven & The Pitbulls vs. Taz & Too Cold Scorpio ist in Ordnung aber auch nichts besonderes. Cactus vs. Sandman ein hartes Barbed Wire Match."
[5.0] "Grandioses Booking! Wurde Bill Alfonso vor diesem Event eher belächelt, ist er nach dieser Veranstaltung der absolute Topheel. Sein Eingreifen in die beiden Main Events hat zu meinem Überraschen bei der doch recht smarten Phillie Crowd heftigste Heel Reaktionen hervorgerufen. Vor allem nach dem, übrigens großartigen, Main Event waren die Fans quasi kurz davor den Ring zu stürmen. Die Undercard war dieses Mal sehr merkwürdig, da ziemlich viele Neuankömmlinge auf der Card standen, was für Events eher unüblich ist. Dreamer-Warrior war ein netter Brawl und das Handicap Tag Match später auch recht ansehnlich, der Rest der Veranstaltung leider unterer Durchschnitt. Allerdings erlebt die Fehde zwischen Tommy Dreamer und Raven wieder einen klaren Aufschwung."
[4.0] "In der Undercard ist sehr viel Chaos, diesmal nicht so positiv wie sonst. Dreamer vs Warrior ist überraschend gut (**1/4). Das Six Man Tag ganz OK (**) und das Debute der Gangstas kommt sehr überraschend. Sandman vs Cactus Jack ist auf jeden Fall ein ECW Klassiker (***), den man gesehen haben muss."
