[9.0] "There is a lot of fun here, not everything is amazing but there's a lot to love if you're an ECW fan. The Raven tag, Eddie/Malenko II, and yet another great Foley/Sandman fight, loved those three quite a lot. First time Taz speaking and doing commentary, hallelujah!"

[6.0] "Not the best ECW show but this was a little bit fun watching. Its just a lot of the fillers had killed it for me."

[2.0] "Dean Vs. Eddie was great, but everything else was godawful. I'm almost giving up on ECW since I've never seen it all the way through before, but this show did nothing to live up to the hype this promotion has received over the years,"

[3.0] "Some of the language in the promos and crowd signs has dated REALLY badly, if this was a decent show it might not bother me so much but this is probably the weakest ECW supercard for a while. It's notable for the debut of Bill Alfonso as the ref who'd insist on wrestlers fighting fair - a genius move, and the best thing on the card. What we get of the Malenko/Guerrero match is great, but there are other matches that aren't edited that are probably more worth watching. Shame the Guerrero/Jannetty match wasn't shown either, I don't think they wanted to focus on anything approaching technical wrestling on this release. There's nothing much here to recommend, it's not unwatchably awful but is dull far too often. A generous 3 points, mostly for the importance of Bill Alfonso."

[4.0] "Like a lot of ECW at this time, you have to wonder what it was that made this company so enduringly popular. The matches are mostly slogs with screwy finishes, the booking is less than great... what's the appeal here? Thankfully Eddie Guerrero and Dean Malenko are here to knock one out of the park. If I'd attended in person I would've left feeling as though I had gotten my money's worth for that match alone."