[6.0] "The show was largely mediocre, with questionable booking decisions like Angle vs. Maria, Shelton's quick loss, and a weak tag match. However, HBK and Carlito, the main event, and some solid promos with Triple H and Big Show and Vince and Bischoff stood out."

[4.0] "Very average show leaning towards poor, mainly because of the booking... Angle vs. Maria in an obvious segment to give Angle heat over Cena, which wasn't going to work, Shelton jobbing to Murdoch in three minutes was ridiculous, the tag title match was a terrible squash match, and the women's match was bad as well. HBK/Carlito and the main event were good as was the HHH/Big Show promo, and the Vince/Bischoff promo was your typical between the two."

[7.0] "Specifically about Kane and Big Show vs Tomko and Snitsky. These two teams should have had a 15-minute classic. Would have been an all-timer as this is just an insane pair of teams. This borderline squash was pretty good too though. Big Show looked very good here with his fulll beard."