[6.0] "A missed opportunity to put the ROH Women's World Television Championship on Zayda Steel. I figured Lethal Twist and Action Andretti were winning the titles in their respective matches. The other titles not moving was unsurprising. The top two matches were the best matches on the card, as to be expected. Why ROH needs 8 championships, I don't know. It's a shame about the Eddie Kingston injury as that match with Ortiz, Kingston & Mancer against RPG Vice & one of the other 23 guys in the DCF had some build."

[8.0] "Once again, ROH PPVs don't disappoint. A really great show with plenty of good matches. The 2 World Title matches were definitely the matches of the night. The ta team title match was perhaps a little too long, while I was pleasantly surprised by the Women's TV Title match because I expected it to be much worse. Aside from the Women Pure Title match, I'd say no match was below a 7/10. And as I said the 2 single World title matches were absolutely fantastic"

[9.0] "This PPV was 10x better than the last and the work rate of all the talents was top-tier. Thank goodness for this crowd, because they added to event in itself and truly made you believe that there was more story than how each of these matches were booked. Even though there wasn't much story to why the majority of these matches were taking place, they eventually mid-way through their respective matches got you believing that there may be in storyline feud internally, which is a great feat in itself."

[9.0] "A really good PPV with some nice specials moments. Loved the second part most, the first two matches were okay, but after that, most of the match were at least good, with at least 5 very good matches."

[7.0] "This show started pretty mediocre for the first half but does end with a real solid final 4 matches with 2 real impressive ROH World title matches beyond that the Pure title match is the only match really worth checking out of the first 5 matches if you are a fan more of the grappling aspect of wrestling of holds and counters. Overall I'd say this was a good 7.5 show. Nick Wayne is becoming a real impressive in ring performer. Kinda low-key was hoping he would pull it off and become the new ROH world champion."

[9.0] "I really enjoyed this years Death Before Dishonor, there were a couple okay matches and quite a few good matches, overall time wise might have been questionable but still definitely worth watching. Blake Christian, Jay Lethal & Lee Johnson vs Dalton Castle, Truth Magnum & Turbo Floyd: While I am disappointed that Castle and Outrunners lost the titles, it was a solid opening match for the main PPV, the action and in ring psychology was just right, all six involved got their moment in this match, wished Outrunners and Castle would have retained though [***1/2]. Deonna Purrazzo vs Steph De Lander: A fine match between these two, not much you could say about this, Purrazzo winning was obvious here, just a run of the mill standard pure rules match [**1/2]. Red Velvet vs Marina Shafir vs Skye Blue vs Zayda Steel: A solid four way match with Shafir looking great in this, Steel showing she can put in a decent amount of effort, Velvet retaining was nice to see albeit interesting as thought Shafir was gonna take this [***]. Lee Moriarty vs Katsuyori Shibata: Unlike the women's pure title match earlier in the PPV, these two actually matched evenly within the confines of pure rules and had quite an enjoyable evenly contested match, Moriarty retaining was good to see against a tough opponent like Shibata [***3/4]. Mascara Dorada & Mistico vs Dante Martin & Darius Martin vs Matthew Taven & Michael Bennett vs Sammy Guevara & The Beast Mortos: Four teams trying to prove that they are the best in ROH by trying the claim the tag team titles in a match that was great from bell to bell, there was some nice lucha sequences, all four teams got their moment in with Dorado and Mistico retaining which was good to see [****1/4]. Daniel Garcia vs Adam Priest: A strong showing from both of these with some nice technical work thrown in for good measure, they connected how they needed to which made this more compelling, would like to have seen Priest get the win here [****]. Action Andretti vs Lio Rush: They had an excellent match with some nice moments and Rush having his ring gear like Sabu was a nice touch, the ending was strange though when The Opps came down to help Andretti win [****]. Bandido vs Nick Wayne: Wayne rose to the occasion even in defeat, Bandido and Wayne put on a great match which was better than I was expecting, Bandido retaining whilst obvious was good to see, a couple of OMG moments like Bandido throwing Wayne onto the steps that Wayne went head first [****1/2]. Athena vs Hazuki: What a main event, Hazuki represented STARDOM in a big way even if she did not win the title, Athena continued to show that she is the best of the ROH women's division, the match was awesome and they connected quite well and managed to put in a hell of an effort [****3/4]"

[8.0] "This was a great match, a lil overbooked, they could've shaved this match down by five minutes, but never the less a great championship contest, very physical. Hazuki has been one of the best overall workers in Stardom & Athena always has good matches with the Joshi girls, like her matches with Syuri. Another nice defense from Athena ****"

[6.0] "Some good matches, some that didn't land for me, and some that were leading to good and had things that I really disliked. Moriarty/Shibata & Priest/Garcia were very good change of pace matches and the main event was good despite the interferences"

"Tremendous ppv, culminated by two incredible championship matches. The future is in good hands with Nick Wayne and Hazuki, and the now is humming right along with Bandido and Athena. Lio/Andretti was incredible as well as the women's 4-way and men's pure rules. An all around excellent evening of professional wrestling."

[8.0] "Four incredible matches, while the rest felt a little too much like a weekly show. It's not easy to build a ROH PPV, and that's why you need some involvement from AEW and other affiliated promotions. But it was structured well, and the result was still a really good PPV overall. I probably would have changed one of the two major titles, but we still got Nick Wayne launching himself not only into the ROH main event scene but potentially into the AEW main event scene as well. It would be great to have Hazuki around full-time too maybe someday... We also got a nice push for Andretti. Other than that, there wasn't much to talk about aside from the excellent Lee vs. Shibata match, but overall it was a very enjoyable PPV."

[6.0] "A show that did not need to be four hours much like many of the Tony Khan ROH PLEs. No bad matches on the show but some that felt overlong (or overbooked in some cases) while others could have used more time. The Philadelphia crowd made for a good atmosphere despite the lackluster build in the lead up to some of the matches here. Best matches of the show were Moriarty/Shibata, Priest/Garcia, Bandido/Wayne & Athena/Hazuki but one did not leap off the page the most for me out of those with the three mentioned title matches in having zero suspense over the results. A notable result here for Jay Lethal to become the first wrestler to hold every title there is for a male wrestler to hold in ROH. 6-6.5"

"Why does every wrestling show have to be a marathon? Bandido vs. Nick Wayne was great, and so was Lio Rush vs. Action Andretti, but when only 2-3 matches stand out on a 13-match card, the show feels way too bloated. Not every event needs to be an endurance test. Cut the filler and give us a tighter, more focused show. Why is this the norm in this business now! :("

[9.0] "I really enjoyed this show. At no point did I feel bored or let down by the action, which is all I look forward to. They probably should have switched the final two matches - there was no suspense in Athena's match, where there were several times when it looked like we could have had a new World Champion. Other than that, though, I don't have anything negative to say."

[10.0] "No matter every time they ever produce a show for Ring of honour pay-per-view's. It doesn't matter if it's two month break four month or they go nearly over a year without doing a show for ring of honour to have the top of the top talents and all the championships depended on a pay-per-view status show. Man, they will forever and always just deliver and produce some of the best wrestling on a weekend that has people actually excited to watch for their time off of work or anything of that matter. TK, WE APPRECIATE YOU. Loved this ppv so much, such a fantastic watch."

[6.0] "I really was not that impressed by this show personally. I thought the latter end of the show went on for way too long. Especially in the World Title Tag Four Way match and the Andretti Rush match which both started good and fell the longer they went."

[10.0] "Again this might be getting the "I was there live" bump but it was a great show. Really fun atmosphere for as much as I hate navigating too and from 2300. Not a bad match on the card. Adam Priest has some great energy live. Hazuki is fantastic, I'd love to see more of her AEW/ROH. Just a great night."

[8.0] "[8.1] The first two matches here are really not my thing for various reasons. Lethal Twist/Castlerunners was just alright but its really sunk by LT taking the win. Aside from the fact Jay Lethal's got accusations, he's incredibly washed and shouldn't be near a title conversation whatsoever. It feels like the win happened mainly for the 'Jay Lethal has held every mens title in ROH' stat and I hated it. Things don't improve from there, as we go into a kind of middling match between Steph De Lander and noted fan of the worst thing to happen to womens basketball in 2026, Deonna Purrazzo. On top of any enjoyment I may have had of Purrazzo going directly into the bin over that, this just wasn't that good. It feels like we've seen the whole 'Purrazzo demolishes a woman who doesn't know how to use pure rules' story very often and adding on SDL's hardcore elements didn't do much. That said, after that, it's all gas with one exception. The Women's TV 4way was great, I really thought Shafir might take it for a second. Moriarty/Shibata was fantastic as expected, the tag title match was pretty fun, Sammy Guevara's in it but I'm really loving Kingdom's new, like, AI Cognitive Atrophy gimmick way more than I expected to, and it made for pretty good comedy, in part because its fun seeing AI bros get depicted as the total losers they are. Garcia/Priest was also fantastic even if the winner was never in doubt whatsoever. Andretti/Rush was pretty good up until the ending where HOOK appeared. I could say more but is there really any need to. Bandido/Wayne had a kind of slow first half and then was all killer for the second, and Athena/Hazuki was great. Overall, pretty good show. Definitely check out the Women's TV title 4way, Moriarty/Shibata, Garcia/Priest, and the two world title matches."

[9.0] "On paper this show honestly didn't look like much but I think it overdelivered. It was way too long but that's to be expected with Tony Khan show's at this point. Make sure you check out both ROH World title matches and ROH women's tv title four way."

[10.0] "A great return to form for ROH PPVs after the underwhelming Supercard of Honor a few months back. The last two matches here were incredible, with a star making performance for Nick Wayne and Hazuki and Athena just tearing it up. Rest of the show was a lot of fun as well, and the crowd were hot all night and into everything which always adds to a show. My only complaint is the status quo we're stuck in. Athena has been a tremendous champion but we're going on four years now, and it kind of feels like Bandido should move on from being ROH Champion as well. Time for something new."