[8.0] "Isla Dawn, Skye Blue and Harley Cameron all in one match = a winner! I like all three of them, but especially Isla Dawn, who I first began watching during her WWE UK tenure. Harley looks different all of a sudden. I guess it must be her attractive new hairstyle. I could not decide who to cheer for between Skye and Harley. It was a solid match, even though the ending was a bit of a letdown. Isla almost came back in her match with Mercedes, but Mercedes is a very tough wrestler. Anyway, I kind of like it when Isla loses her matches."
[7.0] "Fairly good show in advance of All In. I really liked the Speedball trios match and Mortos vs. Takeshita was really good as well. Kind of filler but good wrestling is good wrestling."
[7.0] "I actually prefer this to the dynamite we got. Mercedes had a solid showcase, then Willow cut a fine promo. Moxley talked for longer than needed because of course he did. 6 man tag was excellent. 12 man tag was decent and had a good finish, despite some hiccups. The post match brawl at least made sense. Harley returned. Curious to see where they go with Steven Borden and the main event was good."
[9.0] "Isla Dawn, Skye Blue and Harley Cameron all on the same show! Future Trios Champions The Dogs with a squash win. Fun main event with Takeshita and Beast Mortos. Match of the night was the 12-man tag. Absolute entertainment. Loved it. Had me laughing, had me engaged. So much fun. Bang Bang Gang Guns Up!"
[5.0] "A pretty average episode of Collision with a few good moments but very little that felt important. Takeshita versus. Beast Mortos was easily the highlight, while the Jericho trios match was fun enough despite being mostly a spotfest. Mercedes Moné versus. Alba Dawn was solid, but the rest of the card ranged from forgettable to unnecessary, and several segments struggled to create much momentum. With All In so close, this simply did not feel like a particularly meaningful show."
[3.0] "There are a few scraps of angles with a Don Callis/Sting Junior segment, and a few teams expressing interest in going for the trios titles. Nothing else really advanced anything, and the matches were so mediocre that by the time the main event neared its finish, and they were performing crucifix bombs and other high-impact moves, I was plain-faced and yawning. There's not a single match on this which is must-see because of its attached angle."
[2.0] "A Collision in the vein of Dynamite. Uninspired matches and very little to go on for Hyper All In. Poor Scots, who must have been excited about having both shows before the biggest PPV of the year, and instead they get this. The final segment and the one featuring Borden offered a little something, but it was nowhere near enough. Match quality: 1.25/6.5. Angles and non-match segments: 0.5/3.5. Bonus/penalty: none. Total: 1.75/10. Show watched on MyAEW."
[4.0] "One of those "just go out there and wrestle, idc" collisions. Problem lies with the lack of truly good matches. Not as aggravating as the go-home dynamite, but not a show I particularly enjoyed either."
"[8.0] All things considered, a pretty good Collision. Mone vs Dawn was a very hyped up match, with the Glaswegian taking the pin, unfortunately, but still a good match. The Jerico trios match was a pretty good match, with Nick Wayne being geered with "where's your mommy" chants. Spotfest of a match, but spotfest doesn't necessarily mean bad. DCF had a segment that was okay, but they were being booed so heavily that you couldn't really make out what they were saying. Takeshita vs Beast Mortos is MOTN, with both putting forth an amazing match, and Kyle Fletcher staring down Takeshita ahead of All In. Skye Blue vs Harley Cameron was okay at best. I left before the end of the 12-man tag due to unfortunate circumstances, but overall, a good ass show. No New Day or Ilja tho."