[8.0] "Solid night of wrestling, Jevon never disappoints, Moose rocked up, and Jacy impressed me too. Good stuff"

[7.0] "Pretty decent show with a couple of good matches (first and last). I guess we just saw Je'Von Evans' last match on NXT before his definitive arrival to the main roster. In addition, and despite not being one for the ages, I kinda enjoyed Izzi's promo."

[6.0] "Decent episode. The wrestling was at a nice standard, and we got a good promo segment involving Tatum and Izzi. It did its job of building towards New Years Evil."

[6.0] "Just a normal episode. Matches on a usual level with a banger in the main event. I liked the segment between Tatum Paxley and Izzy Dame and it was only one intresting segment on the ring, what isn't good. NXT Year Awards is ok, but they can do it better. Overall, fine show, especially for taped episode. The ending of 2025 wasn't great, like year overall, but we hope that 2026 will be much better."

[6.0] "this show felt like it was made just because they had to fill the date, not much happened as almost all the build to New Year's Evil happened in the previous episode the only relevant thing was the good main event match"

[6.0] "Pretty good first and last match. Inbetween not much going on. Just what youd expect from the final night. Most air is out"