[4.0] "I mean, the work here was solid and we got a surprise appearence by Moxley, but this shows feel like they don't build to anything anymore"

[5.0] "Was originally only gonna give it a Four, but the Shibata x Jordan Oliver match perked me back up, even if it was a bit short. Main Event was aslo decent. The Premier Athletes are always safe and solid hands and almost any constellation of the Conglomeration will at the very least provide a fun match. The rest of the show was a bit too jobber / enhancement heavy."

[4.0] "A subpar and lackluster follow up to Death Before Dishonor serving as a reminder of how there is only ever real effort by Tony with making the PLEs matter (while those cards still often feel thrown together at the last minute) while the weekly show gets forgotten about. So much of the show feels sterile with running in place with the same things over and over again. Random Athena squash while nothing is on the horizon, random Lance Archer squash which he has been doing for years now, random SAP win over locals, champions appearing in pretapes and not appearing on the show they are very champion of, matches pieced together from various arenas taped before and after in front of less energetic AEW crowds with little overall reason to be invested (adding to the feeling of this weekly show feeling thrown together, ) and little build toward anything. It all blends together and has shown zero sign of changing with Tony Khan as booker for the promotion, a label he has now had for ROH for 3 1/2 years. Jordan Oliver and Shibata may have been a more memorable match anywhere outside of the AEW umbrella."

[5.0] "Way to many squash matches and only a few really interesting matches. Besides that some decent moments, but felt mostly like a skipable episode"

[6.0] "This was an easy to watch show, a number of good matches and it's good to see guys like Moxley show up here"