[6.0] "A show of all time. I skipped the first three matches, so no judgement on those, but the ZSJ Max match is very entertaining, the Ishii Takeshita match is solid, watched the Bill match but nothing to say about it; and I skipped the GOA match, but the main event was good so there's that at least."

[8.0] "2nd Collision I've watched. 8/10! Just a great show! This and Dynamite were really good this week. First match was pretty good, was a nice match but kinda happened out of nowhere so Idk what was going on (at least for someone who hasn't watch much) Good to see Isla Dawn getting work, I liked her in WWE. Match was fine this time around, wasn't super good or anything, but was her first match back in a bigger company. Aminata/Willow vs Triangle of Madness was a good match! Liked it a lot! Max Caster's Open Challenge was fun I liked the crowd going along with it and the match afterwards was short and sweet. Takeshita vs Ishii was a really good match the crowd even gave it a standing ovation, just a great match all around! Big Bill vs Mark Andrews was fun a fun squash match, Bill seems like a cool character. NGL I must've missed TOA vs Young Veterans because I don't remember that match lol. Lastly the Young Bucks vs Paragon was just a great match as well! I like these Young Bucks and I also like Paragon from when I remember NXT! These shows are getting better as I watch haha."

[5.0] "The main event and Take/Ishii were satisfying in-ring performances, but like most of the matches on this card, they lacked stakes and suspense, which limited my enthusiasm for this show. Aside from matches lasting over 5 minutes, there weren't any memorable angles, but I enjoyed seeing Isla Dawn, although she received relatively little attention. I would have liked Grado to make an appearance for the open challenge, but ZSJ's appearance also made sense given FD's lineup. In-ring quality: 2.25/5. Angles and non-match segments: 0.5/3. Bonuses/penalties: none. Total: 4.75/10. Show seen on AEW Plus."

[8.0] "Another really good top to bottom collision with 2 fantastic matches and a really great crowd. AEW TV just doesn't miss"

[8.0] "Push Megan Bayne to the Moon. Tired of Hart & Blue jobbing out to Willow. Takeshita is becoming one of the top guys in the company."

"One of better collison episode of 2025 i really enjoyed this show, it was a great card for the sickos."

[6.0] "A solid show that was the usual Collision special of matches where you knew the results before the bell rang and some OK remaining build to a Forbidden Door card that would feel like any other AEW PPV. Takeshita/Ishii was pretty good but with Ishii always losing on AEW TV to win on ROH soon after it is much of the same. Pretty good main event but not at the level of matches ReDRagon and The Young Bucks had with a flat ending."

[8.0] "Pretty good show! I was glad to see Isla Dawn and Mark Andrews get opportunities in AEW, though it's a shame to see them used as enhancement talents given their skill. Max Caster is killing it. The Nigel and ZSJ exchange was really cool. Always nice to see Rocky Romero. Lots of good stuff, excited for the PPV."

[9.0] "Awesome show. 2 hours tonight flew right on by. The Bucks are doing some amazing work right now, I laugh every time. A good bounce back from only 3 matches on Dynamite to 8 matches tonight. Happy to see GVY again, I've never seen Isla Dawn wrestle but thought she was impressive in a squash. Ishii vs Takeshita was great. Only thing keeping this from being a 10 was I'm not too huge on having 3 squashes on a go home show but other than that no complaints."

[8.0] "8 matches in two hours is part of why I love AEW. They're not too heavily oriented towards promos.. not that promos are a bad thing but they can take up too much air time. The first match was fun and it was nice seeing Hiromu again, and he got the pin again! This match was fun even if it felt a bit pointless. The second match had Megan Bayne basically squash Isla Dawn. Meh. I like Isla Dawn, she can work and has a great look, but she gets squashed in her debut. She barely got any offense in and I don't think she will be used much when AEW has such a large women's roster. The women's tag match was pretty good and it's always nice seeing QA in the ring given how impressive her striking is. Triangle of Madness are a fun team with a cool look but I'd like to see them develop more team moves. ZSJ vs Max Caster was too quick to be really good, but those who aren't familiar with ZSJ's style got a short taste of it prior to FD. He's very agile and technical, very fluid transitions. This was actually my first time seeing him live (Well, not really because this event wasn't aired live either lol). Takeshita vs Ishii was my favorite match of the night. Two amazing Japanese wrestlers with good chemistry. Ishii does his thing, you know with the crazy feats of strength, the hulking up, no selling etc and everything Takeshita does looks so smooth and crisp. He had trouble putting Ishii away which made for a fun intense match. Big Bill quickly took out Mark Andrews. I didn't watch the Gates of Agony match and the Young Bucks match was hilarious as they were introduced as "Rod and Todd". Match quality was overall very good but AEW loves their fair share of squash matches too."