[5.0] "A mid standard ppv but quite funny. Honestly is not a ppv unmissable, but if you have 2 free hours you can very well see it, the only 2 matches above the average are Holloway vs Mathers and the Main Event, for the rest the level is beetween average and bad EDITED"
[3.0] "What a way to kick off the mania week with the most boring show possible. Didn't really pick up until Kylie Rae vs. Zayda Steel but even saying that was good is questionable. I got excited for Marcus Mathers who out of everyone is the most exciting preforming in the tournament. The 6 man with the guys from WWE's EVOLVE was pretty sick with a fun beat down that followed from the heels. Swipe Right is gonna be big in WWE, hopefully."
[5.0] "Standard developmental indy show. I find it very cool WWE is doing stuff like this but the ID program has a long way to go...I think it will get there eventually. Mathers and Holloway stole the show IMO."
[6.0] "I enjoyed the show. Crowd was pretty quiet outside of the final two matches and the three-way. Final two matches were the must see matches on the card with Mathers and Holloway barely squeaking out the main event for me personally. GAL vs Rourke and Steel vs Rae were also very good matches. Most disappointing match was the three-way."
"The show was okay but a fun way to start of the Indy shows for Mania Weekend. Marcus Mather vs Sam Holloway was a good match. I was shocked by the winner of Kylie Rae and Zayda Steel."
[2.0] "First five matches were dreadful or painfully dull - they were definately WWE style and not GCW style even with Cogar's scewers. Top two matches were good but can't save such a terrible start."
[6.0] "A show that picked up more with the last three matches after a bit of a middling start with three matches with relatively cheap endings in a row from match 2-4. Kylie Rae/Zayda Steel was a solid match and the best of the show to that point. The No DQ match between Mathers and Holloway was solid in the first bigger feud within the WWEID system. The main event was enjoyable albeit a bit long. 5.5-6"
[7.0] "Developmental wrestling thrives on potential, but even the most promising talent can't sustain marathon shows. The magic happens in concentrated doses, when fresh faces get just enough time to shine without overexposing their rough edges. Tournament formats exacerbate the challenge, stacking similar work-in-progress matches back-to-back until even engaged fans glaze over. This was fine for what it is."
[6.0] "Most of the matches were just okay, there were a couple that were good to start to showcase the WWE ID Program and what it is about. Jordan Oasis vs Freedom Ramsey: This was only an okay match, nothing memorable happened here, served it's purpose of showcasing what the WWE ID Program is about and there was not really many reactions from the crowd [**1/4]. Zara Zakher vs Izzy Moreno: A short match that had distractions from Swipe Right and Jackson Drake as well as Zayda Steel, Steel attacking Moreno with a trainer while referee was distracted was not good [*3/4]. It's GAL vs Aaron Rourke: It was a solid match for the most part until the end when It's GAL hit Rourke with a low blow while the referee had his back turned, the action was fairly solid [**]. Ice Williams vs Aaron Roberts vs Atticus Cogar: A fine three way match with the limited time they had they had an okay showing, Fuego Del Sol coming out and costing Cogar the match was interesting to see [**]. Kylie Rae vs Zayda Steel: Rae carried this match as Steel was not that good in this one, the match was average at best if I am being honest [**]. Marcus Mathers vs Sam Holloway: Solid No DQ match between two wrestlers who are familiar with each other, they had a solid showing and Mathers winning was good to see, did enjoy watching it [***]. Brad Baylor, Jackson Drake & Ricky Smokes vs Cappuccino Jones, Jack Cartwheel & Sean Legacy: This was a quick paced trios match that was fairly easy to watch and all six involved got their chance to showcase what they can do, was 21 minutes needed, might have been better if there were 4-5 minutes cut off the time but it was still decent [***3/4]"
[4.0] "This was mostly an average event or below that. Holloway versus Mathers was the best matcch of the show, followed by the main event. Kylie against Zayda was disappointing. Steel is still very green in the squared circle."
[5.0] "It was an okay show and a nice way to expose new talent to the masses. But the production of this show made it seem so poor. The lighting in both the arena and on the entrance ramp made it seem like the smallest of indy shows. Also in my opinion the there was too much interference from the same guys at one show. Still an enjoyable way to kick of Mania week for me."
[5.0] "Some of the booking decisions were disappointing, a bit too much focus on screwy finishes in the early part of the show. Mathers vs Holloway and Steel vs Rae the best of the tournament matches. The main event was also great. As for the overall show itself, the production is all off. Prazak can be heard complaining about their mics cutting out intermittently on commentary, the sound from in the room is almost impossible to hear and so you really cannot get a gauge of how the crowd enjoyed the show, that also takes you out of it a little as you don't feel part of things as a viewer of the show on stream."