[5.0] "The wrestling on this show was not the priority as they wanted to go bigger. Scramble was sloppy in my opinion. The Clusterfuck was filled with bad comedy and one person dominating but had a good moment with the winner. You know you are going to get when you watch it though."
[8.0] "I love my GCW Giant stupid mania weekend gimmick show. It's the only show where I honestly cannot guess who wins and what's going to happen. I had a lot of fun, I usually always do. It was really nice of GCW to pick Brodie Lee Jr. to win. I gotta respect GCW, sure it's a mess of a show but it's a fun mess."
[7.0] "watched the replay so I was able to skip downtime but I could see how that could be kinda annoying to others. still a pretty great show that fit the clusterfuck theme which is to add so many people and not take it serious while having good fun. prior years it was tough but this year, I enjoyed it alot. would be cool if they do the GCW V JCW angle they were teasing in the battle royal, as thats a stacked gcw side and id be up to see the jcw crew as they had some people I knew right off the bat with Mickie Knuckles."
[6.0] "The end of Mania weekend, well, for my reviews at the least. WWE reviews on here are so... bleh. I'll just enjoy those shows without comment (well, definitely over these Mania weeks). Enough, rambling, Clusterfuck and independent wrestling! This is very much a show to just turn off your brain and watch, it's not about match quality, and that's fine. The cage match was entertaining, non-sensical with no real effort to sell and an excess of destroyers but this is what this show is for. The Clusterfuck was stupid and dragged indefinitely, as it should. Perhaps it could have been structured a bit better, as there was a good ninety minutes of nothingness? Ah, fuck. Who cares. Invisible Man made his not-so-triumphant return, MLD continued to get some of the biggest pops of the whole week and Brodie Lee Jr got the heartfelt win. A fun end to a fun week of independent wrestling. ***."
[5.0] "The best LOL moment of Mania weekend where its way too late at night or early in the morning for anyone to care anymore so this is lighthearted almost "non-canon" way to end the Collective. The rating isn't for match quality or anything like that, but for the good times. Not as good as last years but still very fun."
[5.0] "This show was exactly what you wanted it to be. It had a couple comedy spots, a genuinely kinda heartfelt ending and yah. Just unlike other years this one dragged quite alot for me but still it was a fun show that started late and ended even later."
[6.0] "The Clusterfuck is one of my favorite things about Mania week, and this year was no different along dragged out match with tons of comedy spots, and that's a good thing. Brodie Lee Jr. winning at the end was a nice way to end the Collective 2025."
[8.0] "The final collective show of the weekend which delivered on it's fever dream promises. Won't be for everyone but for the ones this is for highly recommend."
[6.0] "Das Clusterfuck war lang, sehr lang. Hatte aber einige gute Momente zu bieten, allen voran Brodie Lee Jr.und am Anfang die Up Up Girls. Leider gab es auch einfach zu viele Längen im Match. Das Cage war ein netter Bonus. Zwischen den beiden Matches gab es eine viel zu lange Pause.."
[4.0] "It took 30 minutes between matches despite the fact they apparently got the cage down pretty quickly. That is fed levels of disrespecting your audience so maybe the rumours of the buy out are true after all."
[6.0] "Das Scramble Cage Match war kein schlechter Einstieg und ich fand es auch gut, dass es nicht übermäßig lang war. Umso länger war dann das Clusterfuck Battle Royal Match und da muss man sagen, dass es insgesamt (wie auch die Show als Ganzes) klar hinter der Ausgabe aus dem letzten Jahr zurückblieb, weil man hier im Mittelteil mehr Leerlauf hatte. Man hatte aber einen tollen, unterhaltsamen Start und dann auch eine starke, emotionale Schlussphase und das in Addition mit ein paar weiteren, coolen Momenten führt das zu einem - wie ich finde - immer noch anständig, weswegen ich 6 Punkte gebe."
"Sabu and Joey going to be the best match I think. Barb wire match. The last time Sabu was in this type of match was in Ecw barely legal against terry funk."
