[6.0] "This was a very frustrating show to rate as a whole. The main card is pretty good for the most part, but the main event came along and was one of the worst I've seen for a big show since possibly the NOAH Ibushi match earlier this year. If the semi-main wasn't so good, I'd definitely be rating this show lower, but I absolutely loved it and it made the event worth watching overall I suppose. [MOTN: Esfinge vs. Euforia vs. Hechicero vs. Valiente]"

[7.0] "For the most part this was a decent event, but the main event let it down. Futuro, Hombre Bala Jr & Max Star vs Magia Blanca, Magnus & Rugido: Was not too long, allowed the younger talent to showcase what they can do in a short and sweet match, just what the opener needed to be [**1/2]. Angel de Oro, Niebla Roja & Soberano Jr vs Neon, Star Jr & Templario: Soberano Jr and Templario deliver when they are in the ring, and they did not disappoint in this one, everyone involved had their moment which was good to see, a good undercard trios match [***3/4]. Titan vs Mascara Dorada: While this was a decent enough match, it was lacking something that could have took it to the next level, could have had so much more in this one [***]. Zeuxis vs Willow Nightingale: This was an okay match, nothing more than fine, could have been booked better and Willow should have retained instead of losing it on her first defense [*1/2]. Atlantis Jr, Ultimo Guerrero & Volador Jr vs Orange Cassidy, Rocky Romero & Satoshi Kojima: This was a good trios match, Romero and Volador always have good chemistry and look forward to a singles match hopefully down the road, OC transitioning into a midcard heel for this one made sense and they did it in a way that makes him look credible, always good to see Kojima even in CMLL [**3/4]. Hechicero vs Esfinge vs Euforia vs Valiente: One of the best lucha libre matches in 2024, everyone did what they needed to do, the action was solid as expected, the match flowed in a way that made it credible for the 36 minutes, nothing fell out of place and it was enjoyable throughout, should be considered a contender for MOTY [****3/4]. Mistico vs Chris Jericho: This match was not good, I mean Jericho is so out of shape in 2024 that he should not be in a main event level match, the match pace was slow as anything, and the match did not feature anything interesting, the only good thing was Mistico winning but apart from that what were CMLL thinking putting this match in the main event [*1/4]."

[7.0] "Overall a good show, but man, those last two matches really should have been swapped. About the main event: I'm of the opinion that it wasn't as bad as people say it is - the issues with it have layers. Jericho tried to do his match, adapting to the two out of three falls format, a bad idea given his opponent. Mistico, as over as he is, is a one dimensional wrestler. He has his spots, and formula - if you deviate from it, you start to get performances that can start to look like Sin Cara. Realistically, the ideal format for this match would have been like this. Mistico gets his shine early. Big Bill interferes, Jericho gets heat. Mistico gets the hope spot, until he tries the moonsault and Jericho gets his feet up, with Mistico smashing his face on them. Jericho gets more heat until Mistico does the comeback. Superkick, plancha, tijeras, claps to get the crowd going, Mistico applies la mistica, Jericho taps out, and everyone goes home happy. They didn't do that. Alas...Euforia vs Hechicero was by far, the match of the night. 2nd and third match were also very good, and I'm surprised that Mascara Dorada didn't win, he is very protected in CMLL."

[8.0] "Not exactly the homerun you would think, but the highs in this show were very very high. Show starts off with a two trios and while the first tag was a good match, the Soberano/Templario trio tag was one of the shows highlights. Fast, fun, and great performances from everyone. Mascara Dorada and Titán puts on another amazing match in this show although it may be a disappointment from their amazing match last year. However, both showed up for this show and they put on an awesome match. Very good. Willow and Zeuxis had so much potential to be amazing but it was just good. Which isnt a bad thing! Many good spots and super cool finish. Six man tag had a rough start. Before it got good, there were weird spots and some choices that seemed off. But once everyone started to feel a momentum, they all worked super hard and had a great finish. It was good from that point on. Orange and Volador have great chemistry. Okay the Mask 4 Way match. Might be one of the best matches of the year. So much emotion into this match that its hard to really describe. Every worked so good from the start but Hechicero was on a different level. Amazing match and the end was fantastic. Main event I wouldnt call it a disaster but it was a disappointment. For an anniversary show, it didnt reach the level it couldve, but it was a great show overall and had one of the best matches of the year/decade in it."

[7.0] "This show shoudl have been a ten and up until the apuestas, was on its way to be an easy show of the year contender. Nearly everyone showed up to give a good performance and some fun matches building up to an epic and incredible four way apuestas that had the crowd on fire, and gave one of the best matches of the entire year. Sadly for those workers the show ended on the worst note possible, Jericho/Mistico deflated the crowd to the point it began chanting for the winner of the mask match near the end of it. Using the main event of the most historic event in wrestling, 91 years of CMLL to further an AEW midcard angle that will be third from the bottom on WrestleDream is ludicrous and really brings down the overall rating."

[8.0] "A overall good show with one incredible match in the semi main event with the mask match. Jericho vs Mistico as the main event hurts the overall rating, it stinks and makes the unaffordable sin of being boring. Titan vs Mascara Dorada was a slightly lesser version of their incredible 2023 singles match. Orange Cassidy was interesting in CMLL as a rudo."

[8.0] "Thought this was a pretty good show overall, the downside is of course not having the mask 4 way being the main event, because even if jericho vs mistico was able to have a good match, it wouldn't have been able to outshine the emotional, magnificent match that came before. Had they switched the placing of these two matches, it would have been an Aniversario to remember."

[6.0] "The mask match was absolutely great, everything else was either awful (looking at you Jericho) or decent although probably below expectations. Let us all pretend that mask match was the main event and never talk about the Jericho match again."

[7.0] "This was the first CMLL I've watched and it didn't disappoint. Great action throughout the show. Definitely lost a few points for the main event but overall I would give this show a recommendation."