[7.0] "This was a good episode with solid matches top to bottom. Rush vs. Kommander was a pretty fun lucha style beatdown, which is something Rush excels at. Konosuke Takeshita and Kyle Fletcher vs. Private Party was a fun match to get the Don Callis Family some momentum now that Osprey left. Kyle O'Reilly squashed GPA. Mariah May vs. Hikaru Shida from the Owen Hart Tournament was the match of the night."

[5.0] "Rampage just feels like the continuation of Dark (Elevation). I would not mind making Rampage the show for the Midcard-Titles and the resp. stories and characters. But in this episode every match besides the main event was just on the card for the sake of being on the card. Show was okay overall but you don't miss a thing by not watching unfortunately."

[9.0] "Good match to kick off Rampage with Rush & Komander, followed by an entertaining tag match between Private Party and the Don Callis Family. Great Easter Egg storytelling going on there. Match of the night was the Main Event. Mariah May with a statement victory over Shida!"

[5.0] "This was an alright show with some decent matches to good matches, but it otherwise felt pretty uneventful. A perfectly average episode of Rampage overall I'd say. [MOTN: Hikaru Shida vs. Mariah May]"

[8.0] "Great in ring action and storyline progression on a Rampage is always great to see, really loved the tag match and super happy to see Mariah really getting this over, the Mariah/Toni act is utterly fantastic and the highlight of AEW atm, RUSH in the Callis family is interesting? But we also just got Trent so idk."

[7.0] "Pretty solid in-ring work across the three non-squash matches and actual story development (which is somewhat rare for Rampage) with the Rush/Callis angle and May's Owen run. They also did a nice job of keeping the Chicago crowd engaged and loud. May/Shida is probably the Match of the Night and worth a watch if you missed the show."

[6.0] "Really good episode of Rampage, card looked good on paper and delivered for most part. Komander vs. Rush was fine. Rush entering in the Don Callis Family is really interesting. Fletcher & Takeshita vs. Private Party was the match of the night, really good tag match. KOR had an alright squash and Roddy Strong is still trying to recruit him in the UK, let's see where it leads. May vs. Shida was a good main event. Overall: the show was good in the end, Joe cut a great promo on Jericho and both the tag match and the main event were quite entertaining."

[5.0] "An average hour of wrestling they dynamite this week was way better but a couple ok matches building towards all in such as mariah may and Toni storm in the owen hart foundation and giving kyle another win the tag match was ok aswell but not the best rampage"

[4.0] "Not a good hour of wrestling, I was expecting more, but for a Rampage it's ok, Rush showed great things as always, but his match wasn't nothing special, and the other two matches were pretty disappointing in my opinion. The crowd was very very hot for the Dynamite, but they couldn't bring 10% of that energy here, and this goes on the wrestlers."

[5.0] "Very average episode of Rampage this week, beginning to think it's one hour of AEW TV too many. I think long term they'll tack it onto the end of Dynamite. The only reason to watch this episode is the Owen Hart semi final which was underwhelming."

[8.0] "I enjoyed this weeks rampage. Rush and Kommander had a great match to start the show. I really hope they have the confidence to use Rush more on Dynamite. The Callis family tag match was really good. I feel like a broken record but Takeshita really should be higher on the card than his current position. It feels like the fans want him there as well so Im not sure why they havent fully pulled the trigger on him. Nice to see Kyle although it was just a quick squash, and Mariah and Shida had a good main event match."