[6.0] "The in-ring portion of this show really shined when it got the chance, which somewhat saved the weak PPV buildup for me"

[5.0] "The in-ring action was good but the build to their biggest PPV of the year is very disappointing, I hope the booking changes soon moving forward or we're watching a product which will have no fan base in the near future."

[5.0] "Mid in-ring action, but good promos building up the Supercard. Contract signing between Athena and Shida is the segment to watch for."

[4.0] "Another middling show with more largely subpar build to Supercard of Honor. Briscoe and Kingston tried to sell it but it feels extremely forced compared to seeing a stronger build up of Mark to this match. Johnny/dalton has at least been built even if it is basically a repeat of a story already done by Dalton/Silas in ROH in 2016. Lee Johnson getting wins to challenge Kyle Fletcher is appreciated but the audience still doesnt feel invested in Lee while Kyle has been booked terribly in AEW. Similarly infantry/OGK was a small program in summer of 2023 that got no payoff and would be sensible for an eventual payoff, preferably without both eating losses on AEW TV."