[8.0] "Above average but wildly uneven with 3 really good matches, a couple of enjoyable to passable ones and 2 bad ones. I enjoyed it more than WWE's Backlash the next night in France. Suffered from the Ash by Elegance and Gresham matches completely killing the crowd until the mustafa ali match. Gresham's heel turn should have been on a tv event and I think scared kids in the audience with fake supernatural mumbo jumbo."

[4.0] "Under Siege was a poor show from TNA. The last two good matches were good and I liked the opener but almost everything else was middling to poor, with most matches undone by bad booking, off storytelling and dreadful gimmicks. I know the interference is a hallmark of TNA but most of it is so poorly done and that's the problem."

"A mix of good moments but some very underwhelming matches. Everything feels a little mishandled at the moment with the booking and the System really isn't doing it for me."

[5.0] "Super mixed show for me with more on the bad and mediocre side than the good side. Still, there were three solid matches on the card that saved the show from being bad for me. However, the questionable booking in TNA is becoming such a concern for me as of now that I don't care to rate this show any higher despite the trio of good matches. [MOTN: Ace Austin vs. Mustafa Ali]"

[6.0] "A show that saved its best for last. Ali vs Austin was my pick for best match of the night; I'm not totally sold on Ali's character - I think he'd be better as a babyface personally - but his matches during this X-Div Title run have been quality overall. The six-man main event comes pretty close though; far overperforming on how it looks on paper, a very entertaining and chaotic brawl and one of Matt Hardy's best matches in a long time. The undercard was much more of a mixed bag - the EY/Alexander vs Kazarian/Maclin opener was probably the third-best match on the show, while Ash by Elegance vs Havok was probably worst of the night (though Ash and George Iceman did at least do some fun character stuff). Gresham vs Kushida was mostly solid, but was primarily a vehicle for Gresham's new character, which I'm not yet sure what to make of. The rest was mostly pretty average and unremarkable."

[7.0] "Was there live and thought the worst thing was the crowd to be honest. Womens matches were also fairly weak outside the mixed tag picking up near the end, but the rest of the card I found pretty satisfactory. Opening tag felt really nice after the news we got about EY and his injured ear. Hendry is as hot as he can get at this point. Swann/Something was a little off with the Deaner stuff and then other parts but was nice overall. I got the Gresham stuff because I was watching the vignettes and expected it to go that way but it landed flat with the crowd. Penultimate match was some of the best I have seen out of Ali since his WWE departure. Also reminded me of how good Ace Austin was as just a singles. Hope those two keep it up. 6 man tag was also really nice. Wasnt the absolute best thing ever but is one of Matt Hardys best matches in the last 5 years that technically wasnt a gimmick. Also reminded me of how good of athletes the system are. Nobody roots for them or likes them or whatever but they are all still really solid wrestlers who pull out moves or strikes you wouldnt expect from them."

[8.0] "This was a good card for a B show with only 2 weeks to build to it. Albany was a hot crowd from Rhino vs VSK to the main event. Good mix of matches with a lot of shenanigans (Ash/Havok) to flat out excellent work (Ali/Austin). Main event might have over-delivered."

[4.0] "Oof...TNA is in pretty bad shape. They're much worse off than they were at this time in 2023 or even the end of '23. Everything feels small. They have a decent roster but they don't look like they're trending in the right direction. Having Matt Hardy in your main event scene, even briefly at this point in his career shows how desperate they are. The matches themselves were ok but there's just no energy in the building. TNA is a good lighting system ahead of the NWA. Everything else feels just as lethargic."

[4.0] "I need a break from TNA. Very average card, nothing that will really stand out from this show. Weird to see Mike Bailey and Trent Seven in Matt Hardy's crappy rant. It's quite disturbing to see him forcing it so much, the delirium has aged badly and isn't at all relevant these days. The System continues to parasitize the company. Only the new arc with Jonathan Gresham seems worth following."

"Shows like this really expose how weak the TNA roster is with their biggest players putting in hokey performances like the main event. A lot of Ali's buzz seemed to wear off almost instantly since signing with this company. Will say this is the best I've seen of Gresham. The mask has always been the best part of his presentation and choosing to wear a version of it throughout the match will only help him."

[6.0] "A mixed show. Opener/Ali & Ace/main event were my three favorites of the night with the Jordynne tag and Gresham Kushida shortly behind. Card getting reshuffled hurt the first portion of the show a bit. Not a bad show but weaker than some of TNAs recent PPVs/PLEs."

[5.0] "A rushed, poorly built card with no big news other than a KOs Tag Title change (which isn't actually that big news). Gresham's character reinvention, the opening tag, and X-Division match work, but this is maybe the most skippable special TNA has has in like a year."