[6.0] "KAIRI's 'final' STARDOM match was surprisingly emotional, MIRAI/Watanabe was a very good White Belt match and AZM/Anou served as a showcase of AZM as a much better pro-wrestler than her opponent, but everything else was underwhelming - Syuri/Shirakawa was good enough but not great, Seira won the High Speed title but it didn't make her look good, trios titles matches was only five minutes for whatever reason and the Main Event was just weak and boring."

[7.0] "I thought this was going to be way worse. However, Natsuko/Tam was better than I thought it was going to be and the AZM/Anou and Momo/MIRAI matches completely over-delivered. Also, KAIRI's swan song was very, very enjoyable too leading me to find the event a nice surprise. Even the Maika/Suzu stuff feels better when looking at it as just part of an event rather than a wasted match. Awesome that Mei won too; she's sure to have a bunch of new and exciting title matches (and, as champion, the Saki stuff was starting to wear a little thin)."

[7.0] "Stardom Nagoya Golden Fight ~Kinshachi Miracle was a great show the card changed a little with injuries happening in the 5star gran prix so there was no tag team title match but the replacement was still a great match between AZM vs Saori Anou. There was 2 good matches and 3 great matches and 2 banger matches on this card."

[9.0] "main event was on the weaker side and it is a damn shame that saki lost the title. other than that a really great show. momo/mirai was match of the night. uwf match and azm/saori both solid. liked the angle at the end of ast title match. kairi farewell match went a little too long for my liking but cant really dislike it."

[8.0] "A good B-PPV on the heels of the end of the 2023 5 Star Grand Prix. All the matches were good and some even exceeded expectations. The Saki/Mei story got a fitting conclusion in the PPV opener, paying off on the buildup in recent months. Saori and AZM had a rematch of their entertaining match from the Grand Prix and for me, it was a better match than the first one. I also thought Syuri and Mina's UWF rules match was really good, and Mina showed off a lot of toughness. That match has a lot of rewatch value in my opinion. The trios title match was fun while it lasted, but the ending and aftermath was very intriguing. They're telling a story with Maika and I hope it leads to her winning a title. MIRAI and Momo's match was very good, but I'll always feel deflated after a MIRAI win. KAIRI's sendoff match was pretty good, but at least five minutes too long. The prematch vignette and aftermath were good, but the match should've been shorter and easier to digest. The main event was refreshing in my opinion, and a welcome shift from the norm for Stardom. It can't be a common match style here, but it worked for Tora and made her come off as a legitimate threat. Poor finish aside, I really enjoyed it. I wish I could give the show a 7.5, because it deserves that. A 7 feels too low, but an 8 might be too high. Regardless, pacing down the stretch and finishing sequence of the main event aside, this was a very good show for what it's supposed to be."