[4.0] "An ECW reunion show in 2024 comes with somewhat low expecations for in-ring quality, and for the most part this lived up to such expectations - a lot of the matches and appearances were geared more to nostalgia pops than any real drive for in-ring quality. The last two matches were easily the best of the lot, with Super Crazy and Tajiri running back their rivalry in a match that started as a regular bout and then turned into a "Mexican/Japanese Death Match" when Whipwreck came out. It didn't quite match up to some of their previous encounters, like the classic death match on ECW on TNN, but considering that was 24 years ago, they did a good job of recapturing at least some of the magic. Juvi vs Scorpio was also a fun little match between two seemingly ageless wonders, though it certainly could have been a lot better with more time given. On the undercard, Rhino vs Tanaka was also pretty solid and might be worth a look. There was definitely a lot of downtime and filler, but if you can put up with that (or fast forward through it) there's enough for the old ECW faithful to latch onto for at least a decent enough time. Not the best ECW reunion show I've seen, but also by no means the worst."

[6.0] "ECW nostaliga all around. This made the show better, but you still couldn't hide the fact that this show came way to many years too late. But I'll give props for booking as many ECW names as possible for this one. Glad I got to see and ECW tribute show in the ECW Arena."

[5.0] "A fine show that gave a lot of ECW alumni another chance to perform in one of the most famous venues in wrestling. There was a stretch toward the middle of the show that felt like it dragged. The main event was the most enjoyable match of the show while the opener was solid as well. I was hoping for a bit more from Scorpio/Juventud but that would still likely be the third best of the show. The farther away from ECW the show got, the more the show dropped. Still a fine show that could have been a bit better with some tweaking here and there."