[5.0] "A pretty good main event, especially by Rampage standards, but hearing Tony Schiavone's humiliating conformity training live on air during the women's match marred this episode for me. I can't wait for the double "Goth girls hang upside down" spot when Hart and Abadon match up. I hope it gets a "This is awesome! " chant. Outside of that, good main event and a fine enough opener. A pretty solid episode outside of the clownish midcard."

[5.0] "Rampage has been completely skippable for a long time now. The only reason I watched this episode was the Danielson - Gracia Match. Danielson vs. Garcia was a great match, but poor Garcia can't catch a break losing week after week. You again saw the same patterns of problems of the companies creative. OC defends his tite against someone who didn't appear in AEW for two months, and mostly was on the undercard. The match was just okay, but was yet again a pointless title match without any build or heat to it. The Don Callis Family vs. Christopher Daniels & Matt Sydal was basically a 8 minute squash match that lasted 5 minutes too long. A really underwhelming match that just felt like it was booked to give the Callis Family something to do. Abadon vs. Trish Adora was a short and bad match. Abadon didn't impress me at all. So it was basically a one match show with the rest being meaningless filler. It's mind-boggling to me how unimportant this show has become, when you could use that hour to build feuds, characters and feature more women who are criminally undervalued in this Company."

[7.0] "From an in-ring perspective, this was a pretty solid episode of Rampage (and one of the better episodes in recent memory). I enjoyed the opener more than I expected to (great match layout for Angelico/Cassidy) and the Main Event was a special match with real stakes. It's worth rewatching. Everything else was story-filler, but the stories they're selling need camera time so it's helpful (esp. the Abadon vs Julia Hart mini-feud they're building)."

[6.0] "Solid Rampage, I think the first two matches were a little below average, and the Abadon match and angle more of the same, but the main event was a classic, completely delivered."

[6.0] "for an one hour show, it wasn't bad. we saw a good main event, which is gonna influence the average point of the show. but beside main event, other things weren't that good and everything else was pretty average. Don Callis Family match was good but from the story line aspect, it has became boring and pointless and they have to do something about it."

[8.0] "Rampage bounced back impressively after that dire showing last week. We opened with Orange Cassidy defending his International Title against Angelico in a very fun match. I wasn't expecting a grounded match based around working the leg, but that's what we got here. People don't target body parts enough in modern wrestling. We then got a quick match between Abadon and Trish Adora. Despite it being only three minutes long, it over stayed its welcome. I don't think I'll ever be a fan of Abadon, although I am intrigued by their relationship with Julia Hart. The Don Callis Family then took on Christopher Daniels and Matt Sydal in a protracted squash. It was fine, but nothing to worry about tracking down. Finally, in an unsurprising Match of the Night performance, Daniel Garcia and Bryan Danielson faced off in the Blue League of the Continental Classic."

[8.0] "Very strong episode of Rampage. I enjoyed the final two matches a lot with the main event being my MOTN. Glad to see Trish Adora in AEW again even in a losing effort. First match was too much comedy and took away from Orange and Angelico too much."

[5.0] "Lot of perfunctory storyline stuff going on in this episode capped off by a great main event. OC's match was like another one of the filler defenses from his first reign. Cool to see Trish Adora on TV again, but that whole post-match thing with Abadon and Hart felt like a re-run of their last encounter. All in all, slightly better than last week's Rampage."

[6.0] "Tag match and main event are worth checking out, especially the main. Callis family need a new target that isn't Golden Jets to get their heat back. Go away from that story for awhile and give Hobbs and Take a new feud to win, then circle back to those dudes later when its time for Kenny to get his win back. Main event was great, lots of emotion and Garcia was a great babyface in it. The ladies match was awful. Ship Abadon back to the indies and send Adora back to ROH. Match was clunky, selling was awful, and Abadon screaming grates my nerves. OC match was skippable filler."

[7.0] "Very good program, better than what happened last week. The first match of Orange vs Angelico was acceptable, but I would say that it is one of Orange's lowest fights in 2023, little mobility and connection between the two. I will skip the short women's match, but I was left with how they are slowly bringing the feud between Abadon vs Julia Hart to a simmer. Personally, I liked the tag team match and especially the end of the match, I feel that the Sydal/Daniels duo needs more opportunities, I like that duo. And finally, the main event, the best of the night, a great match between Danielson/Garcia, where the physical and psychological aspect of the match prevailed during the 15 minutes that both were in the ring. The audience was immersed in the aura that both gave, a great match to end the program. 7/10."

[8.0] "An excellent main event, but the other matches were reasonably entertaining as well. The opener was very slow paced, but worked well, because it's so rare to see such style in AEW. The tag match had plenty of cool feats of strength and skill."

[6.0] "This was a solid show, Rampage has been a little bit of a roll as of late and I'm happy they are following on the show's momentum. Cassidy vs. Angelico was a fine opener, nothing outstanding but both man are good workers and the Serpentico/Danhausen bits were pretty funny. Adora vs. Abadon was just bad, too much screaming and just bad action all around. Let's see what's going to happen between Abadon and Hart, I hope Abadon joins the HoB because that would be the whole reason that would make me care about them. Not really interested in see them fight, Abadon ain't very good in the ring and Julia is still green. Don Callis Family vs. Daniels/Sydal was okay but it's a such a shame that two great wrestlers like Hobbs and especially Takeshita are being wasted like this. Danielson vs. Garcia was an excellent main event, the action was hard-hitting and the counter game of this match was simply wonderful. Garcia brought the Red Death but made the mistake of dancing and that costed him the match. Overall: solid show, mainly because of the main event."

[6.0] "Not a great Rampage this week excepting the main event. I'm not excited for this second OC reign and randomized opponent of the week. Danhausen's shtick adds nothing to the match either. Abadon is just not for me. They spend too much time screaming and the match in general was plodding, full of awful over-acting, and killed the crowd. The Callis family has lost nearly all its heat just circling in these pseudo squash matches. Wish I didn't feel so negatively as Rampage for a while now has been super enjoyable. Anyway, the main event was great, was surprised to hear Garcia getting so many cheers and chants, and Bryan getting booed as he rarely does even when he works heel. Poor Garcia really gonna not get a single win the whole damn tournament."