[5.0] "The vast majority of this show was absolute fluff/filler. It feels like every AAA show I watch (which to be fair, are only the major ones), at least of the event can be skipped right through. However, the segments & matches that weren't filler definitely delivered. Vikingo had another stellar title defense, even if his other two TripleMania matches were better. The Latin American title match was fun and gave us a surprise winner. The main event was nothing to write home about, but Sam Adonis delivered with his post-match promo. Other than that, this is a show that you can feel comfortable missing."

[3.0] "Once again, we get an awesome Vikingo multi-man title defense, this time against Bailey, Cartwheel and Daga. Outside of that match, some of the others - like the main event, the Latin American Title four-way and both women's matches - were OK but unspectacular, and Casas vs. Nicho was underwhelming with a puzzling stipulation for wrestlers of their styles and stature. Further, the emphasis on there being no disqualifications resulted in far too much reliance on outside interference in many of the matches, technical issues took their toll, notably in the Copa (which seemed reasonably fun for what we were able to see of it), and there was a lot of downtime between matches. Of the three Triplemania 2023 events, I thought Monterrey was OK and quite enjoyed Tijuana, but Mexico City was a major step back. Watch Vikingo's match; the rest could probably be safely skipped or sped through."

[3.0] "The first match on the part of such beautiful and Latina females is acceptable; The second Battle Royale-style match is to be seen knowing that it is more entertainment and comedy than Wrestling, but taking that into account, it can be partly enjoyed; I will always highlight the AAA Hall Of Fame compared to other companies that do not even respect what it means to be a Hall Of Fame; The match between Negro Casas and Nicho was nice, but it is not what was expected, but it had good storytelling that stood out; I can't rescue much from the match for the Latin American championship, I can only say that I'm glad that QT is AAA champion, but nothing more; Excellent match for the Mega championship, representation of the Mexican style from wrestlers from all over the world; I really appreciate the work of Cartwheel, I hope you do well from here in the very near future; good stellar match; The truth is that despite everything, I do not think that this Triplemania, even though it is a different style from what is expected, has fulfilled, I even think that the public was unhappy in the arena, I will only say that it is better to move away from what is something formal with the informal, it's Wrestling, not a children's party."

[2.0] "I can't justify rating this show anywhere in the positives because of a genuinely good Vikingo match. Because you've got to wade through a sewer pipe of faeces just to get to that. Not one other match that's worth watching in any way, and with more dead air and time wasting than wrestling otherwise. Including a Hall of Fame entry for someone whose TV matches with AAA only scrape the double digits, and a stupid dance session with a corporate mascot. Had the Vikingo match been off the show, this would be an obvious zero."

[6.0] "After rewatching this show twice and really struggling with what to rate it here we go. Show starts with your typical Triplemaina ceremony that goes for about 20 mins then we get into action. CHIKandTOXICAS/DALYSandSHANIandSTAR- I thought this was a great way to start the show off. Some hot women beating the shit outta eachother with cookie sheets and allright moments. Nice spot where they go through a board on the outside. I coulda cared less for the screwy ref finish but its definitely leading to a father vs son/ref vs ref match in the future that might be entertaining. Also the story with Shani and Chik is allright to, good why to get you excited for their cagematch. 3*. BATTLEROYAL- Some allright spots in this match such as Mr Iguana's elimination and great lucha wrestling from Myzteziz. At one point Pagano makes his return and starts fighting ontop of a forklift and overshoots 2 flaming tables and lands right on the concrete in probably the most unsafe spot of the year. Idrk what else to say the action was allright and the right person won but their wasnt much to this other then this is your typical AAA battle royal. 2*. TAYA/FLAMMER- I loved this match. These two future legends beat the shit outta eachother. Taya takes a trashcan to the head and bleeds buckets. Where is this Taya in AEW she was looking like a badass throughout but Los Toxicas had the numbers advantage thus them breaking Tayas historic run as Reina De Reinas champion. 3and1/2*. CASAS/NICHO- Great legends match(considering AAA's hystory with some others). Had some fun moments, it was crazy to see Casas pulling out moves onto tacks at his age but kinda adds to the insanity of the match. 2*. QT/PENTA/TEXANO/DRAGLISTICO- This is where the paceing of the show kinda messes up for me, idk who thought it would be a great idea to do three 4 ways back to back but whatever. This match was pretty good and had his moments. I feel if Cage was cleared it woulda been his moment but it's cool QT won after that great ambulance match awhile back. 2*. VIKINGO/DAGA/JACK/MIKE- Whatta match! Genuinely up there with one of the best of Vikingos defenses. Bailey is insane and up there as my favorite wrestler currently after this performance aswell. Everyone did there thing. Just go watch this now. 4and3/4*. SAM/LA/PSYCHO/RUSH- I dont even know what to say lmao. Alotta blood and weapons and brawling. I kinda thought Park is kinda washed now and he shoulda lost his mask but I guess they went with the safe bet and chose Sam's hair. I hope after this Sam becomes a beast and does somthing memorable after all this. 2*. Overall just your normal triplemania with interesting outcomes but was overall quite enjoyable. I dont think it was worth the money at all tho but I did have a good time."

[5.0] "Summarily underwhelming PPV that pretty much embodies that state of AAAshoving as much content into each match and hoping something sticks to the wall. Ideally top talent either pushes for more influence/booking or the promotion does a hard reset with any existing storylines..."

[4.0] "You know what you're going into. Just another TripleMania with some good matches being overshadowed byu nonsense and infamously low points. You can enjoy this, if you skip boring mess of the main event and deeply unenjoyable Casas vs. Nicho with all that void AAA added to the show for it to last 4 hous. Sadly, this TripleMania doesn't have real gems of drama or action, but other matches are all pretty good. Sadly, Copa Bardahl was clipped thanks to terrible live stream, but I hope it gets on YouTube soon."