[7.0] "They did a good job honoring Jay's life but the matches weren't great. It wasn't thrown together too well but that didn't take away from the fact of honoring Jay. Rest in peace Jay, the wrestling world will miss you forever."

[10.0] "For the tribute and remembrance of Jay it is a great event, but it is true that there are many irrelevant fights, but one thing does not take away from the other. May you rest in peace Jay. People will remember you in the wrestling world."

[7.0] "Given the tragic circumstances, and how little time they had to organise some sort of tribute, this is a valiant effort to honour Jay Briscoe. However, without the archive footage spliced in an argument could be made that they should have waited a bit longer until they could put together a card that more heavily consisted of people from throughout Jay's career. There's nothing bad on the show, but there were a few matches that felt out of place on it."

[9.0] "As much as I loved the show's structure of having the legendary stars of ROH narrate their times spent with Jay in & out of the ring, I felt a void in this event due to some bouts not having the necessity/power to be a part unlike the opener, Athena/Madison & the main event. The callback contests of the heavenly hero were excellent picks for some to reminisce about and some to watch it for the first time. The major flaw this event had was that the team was held back due to Warner Bros Discovery's constant rejection of conducting this event even though Jay has changed his views on his past comments. The promise was made by the team for another proper tributary event just like how Brodie Lee had & I hope it'll be completely memorable & a perfect foil of the essence of ROH."

[9.0] "Simply a beatiful tribute show, since the live matches and the World Championship Match Main Event, with the kinda "teraphy with the cameras" from the people who meet and worked with Jay and the 3 library matches....Reach for the Sky Boy! Rest in Peace, Jay."

[8.0] "Not factoring the tribute material (including the archival matches), this was something of an average show, feeling somewhat thrown together (likely because it was; taped only 24 hours after Jay Briscoe's tragic passing) with the Claudio-Daniels main event the only real in-ring standout match, and the one that truly felt like it was fought with honoring Jay in mind - a match between one of his great rivals and one of his fellow day-one ROH talents, over a title the man himself held twice, and ending with Jay's finishing move. The tribute material, including the taped testimonials and matches from the archive, though, boost the show greatly, and made it into the loving tribute Briscoe deserved. I can't help but wonder, though, if it might not have actually been an even stronger tribute - as well as easier on almost everyone involved - to cut it down to *just* the archival/tribute material and the main event as a single featured match."

[10.0] "Awesome tribute for celebration of life of a legend , but Jay deserved a live tribute for whatever he had done for pro wrestling . F**k you Warner Bros . CORRUPTED Discovery . You didn't even gave a permission for his dead. SCREW YOU"

[10.0] "Everything for Jay. One of the best tag team wrestler ever, this is the minimum we can do for him, reach for the sky!"

"I don't rate memorial shows, but given that this was put together 24 hours following Jay's passing, it was an excellent tribute. the 3 hour video posted to YouTube had a collection of interviews from his former co-workers, and a few of Jay's best matches with current AEW talent. I wouldn't say these are the best matches of Jay's career, but it's a great showcase to honor a great man."

[10.0] "Beautiful show. Wasn't as much about the in-ring action as much as it was the emotion of celebrating Jay's life. A legend in the business, he will be missed. Reach for the sky, RIP Jay Briscoe. Can't give this anything less than a 10/10."

[10.0] "A beautiful homage to one of the most hard hitting, talented and beloved man in the bussines. Emotional, to say the least; he spent the last decade trying to make up for his mistakes in the past and that deserves, at least, acknowledgement and, preferably, forgiveness. Thanks for the good memories, Jay, you will be missed."

[10.0] "You know, it doesn't really matter if none of the matches were memorable by themselves, because this show as a whole will definitely be. They chose some of the best Jay matches, I would've liked to see his first world title win, but I understand they maybe don't want to promote Steen. I also loved the messages from Samoa Joe, Adam Cole, Matt Hardy, Christopher Daniels and everyone that decided to speak, they really made me shed some tears. Jay Briscoe, you will always be remembered."

[10.0] "A wonderful tribute show honoring the life of a great human that Jay was. We love you Jay and you will live forever inside of all of us! <3"