[7.0] "I think this is a pretty good show, with one of the greatest matches of all time on it. There are some low points for sure and it does feel a little long. We could have done without some of the filler matches like the stuff with the new age outlaws (both their matches) and Roode vs Hardy. But those matches weren't bad, and basically everything else is good. Both hardcore matches were surprisingly watchable; I usually don't like garbage matches but both were good especially Sabu v Abyss. No good promos unfortunately, Petey Williams is especially weak in this department. However, I think this is overall a good watch, even if there are some skippable sections."

[6.0] "One of the greatest matches in history and for me the best triple threat match in the history wasn't enough to make that show good, it's not bad either it was mid the two extreme matches and the showcase of Roderick and Austin were good matches but the others are not that good and some of them are literally just bad"

[6.0] "The main event is one of the greatest professional wrestling matches of all time; unfortunately, you can't judge a show just by the main event and there was a lot of lackluster crap on the card. Raven, Rhino, Abyss, and Sabu all had matches that were the among the best of their careers, plus the two X-Division matches were pretty good. The problem is that the rest of the card was poor-to-mediocre, with 3LK and Mr. Ass dragging things down in their outings as usual, plus surprisingly dull showings from Roode vs Hardy and the tag title match. It's obvious where the fat should've been cut, but TNA inexplicably kept shoehorning garbage onto their PPVs."

[6.0] "For me, it's not such a good show. It doesn't mean it's tragic, but I prefer events rich in high ring level. And here, for me, for one good fight there are two mediocre ones. And of course my event (but this one is on a cosmic level separated from the rest of the show), I just rate the show as mediocre as a whole. However, I understand if someone likes this kind of atmosphere, then the whole thing may appeal to them."

[10.0] "All the tag team action and Hardy Vs Roode were all bad, but Sabin Vs Williams and Raven Vs Rhino are both solid, Aries Vs Strong and Abyss Vs Sabu are both really great and Styles Vs Daniels Vs Joe is a complete masterpiece, TNA's magnum opus and the match that put the whole company on the map of professional wrestling. Overall TNA Unbreakable (2005) is a really fantastic show and definitely TNA's most iconic."

[6.0] "Satisfactory show that gets some overhype on account of the main event. Aries/Strong have a very good match in the undercard and Raven/Rhino pay enjoyable tribute to their Backlash 2001 encounter. The main event is quite good but in my opinion, not the best match in TNA history. Still an incredibly unique match with a lot of great action with all three guys at the top of their game. Some other enjoyable matches like Raven/Rhino and Sabu/Abyss. I wouldnt call it one of TNAs better PPVs though despite the notable main event."

[9.0] "A mostly stellar show that features my personal favorite match of all time in AJ/Daniels/Joe. There are a handful of mediocre matches (the opener, Hardy/Roode, and James/Killings vs Hoyt/Apolo) but besides that everything else is pretty great."

[8.0] "The Main Event is tied as being my favorite match with Savage Steamboat WM3. There really wasn't a bad match on the show. I definitely recommend this show."

[8.0] "An underrated PPV in Wrestling history with son many good match on the card. Even the worst match is ok."

[8.0] "This had an all time great match in the main event and a perfectly solid undercard with one other stand out match. Also Sabu so therefore it is good."

[8.0] "Best known for the main event of Daniels vs. Styles vs. Joe in perhaps the most highly-regarded match in TNA history. That match is indeed quite awesome overall and a must-see for fans of any or all of the three participants. The undercard is also pretty solid, with a good main event in Raven vs. Rhino, two other strong X-Division bouts (Aries vs. Strong and Sabin vs. Williams), a decent hardcore bout between Abyss and Sabu, and a four-way Tag Title match that was fun enough despite Waltman's no-show. Overall a decent show with a killer main event."

[8.0] "Interesting event with great and bad matches. It was the right choice to have the X-Division match in the main event, but even Rhino vs Raven was good. The rest of the card is almost forgettable, with an exception for Aries vs Strong, a good match but not really into the stories of TNA. Also some good things in Sabin vs Williams, but not really different from the usual matches."