[4.0] "There's an iconic Shawn Michaels promo where he mimmicks Hulk Hogan in a Larry King spoof, which was just peak HBK heel work and he has been carrying Raw for weeks now hyping up his feud with Hogan single handedly! There's also a good Vince McMahon promo where he reinstated Matt Hardy and then Hardy gives a passionate promo about the fans and blurs the storytelling with the real life drama with Edge and Lita. The only reason my rating is as high as it is, is on the strength of those two moments because everything else about this show is dreadful! None of the matches are any good and we have.... repeat after me.... another John Cena main event where he has to overcome impossible odds to win. This has been going on for weeks now and its damaging to the rest of the roster, particularly Carlito who was the IC champ dominating the whole match only to lose in like five moves. Absolutely horrendous booking. The Jericho attack on Cena after the match was visceral, but he is clearly playing second fiddle to Bischoff in this feud! There's another degrading Divas Search segment with the insufferable comedy from Rob Schneider where he acts like a total perv throughout the whole thing. This was all to promote a really shitty movie he starred in. The match quality overall is appalling and this has been going on for weeks!"

[5.0] "The promos kept this show from being terrible, especially the Larry King Live spoof with HBK dressing as Hogan, but the matches were all either bad or complete filler and the Diva Search was the Diva Search."