[7.0] "this whole episode of raw was actually pretty good I enjoyed it and the main event and ending segment was good"

[6.0] "The second half of the show was really good, but overall, it was an average episode of Raw. Cage match was great"

[6.0] "I might be a little generous with my rating, only one match really had any substance and it was the result of a blatant bait and switch for the title match. The only other match worth anything was a fun sprint by the women. Yet I do appreciate a story that goes through the night, and the drama within Evolution was pretty well done, right down to being a ploy (though with a hint of truth). Not a bad episode, though not great either."

[8.0] "Despite the fact only one match on this show was of any real length, I thought this was a really good show. The Benoit v Edge cage main event is excellent and a very physical match. The Women's Title match was one of the matches I wish went on a little longer too, but I also enjoyed that one for what it was too and the Lita/Trish feud is really good. Batista v Jericho was also a sprint, but another one that got the point very quickly and really made Batista look like an animal in there. The best thing about this show though without a doubt is the Evolution storyline where there are constant teases Triple H and Batista are going to brawl and it all turned out to be a swerve at the end to get Triple H out of his title match. This was still a lot of fun to see as the seeds was definitely planted for the two to collide! This had a really good flow to it and overall was very entertaining. The only weaknesses here really was the 6-man tag only getting a short amount of time and Johnathan Coachman continuing to wrestle."

[6.0] "The first hour was very weak outside of Benoit's promo, while the second hour was your typical strong 2004 Raw, with a really good cage match."