[4.0] "Not terrible but not exactly a thrilling episode of Smackdown. Tons of attention on the Tough Enough contestants making out with Mae Young, which is about as exciting as you would expect. None of the matches were great but none were awful either, the Eddie/RVD tag was match of the night."
[3.0] "There is at least some build up for the Survivor Series PPV on this show, which by default makes it a better show than last week. It's still a terrible show overall though because of the terrible storylines, wrestling and segments dominating the show. Despite the stupid way Cena was written off the show, it is exciting to have him announced as Eddie's last teammate, however he doesn't show up on the show at all which somewhat weakens the main event which is essentially an extended heat segment for the uninteresting heel team. There's a decent Eddie/RVD carry job in the tag match, and the Cruiserweight tag is fun while it lasts but that's about all I can say about the positive side of things. The main event feud gives us a terrible Jordan vs Matthews match and the show is still dominated by the terrible Tough Enough segments, which this week was Diva Search levels of awful with the extremely played out Mae Young jokes! Fair play to Mike Mizanin for ending up with a great career with the WWE as it is a miracle he managed to make it past segments like this!"
[2.0] "Sehr schlechte Ausgabe von SmackDown. Das Anfangssegment war grauenhaft. Der Torrie Wilson Sex Test klingt ja super doch wenn man Mae Young erwähnt beginnt das Loskotzen. Absolut grausam das ganze für unerbitterliche 20 Minuten Zeitverschwendung. Daniel Puder gewinnt und Nick Mitchell muss gehen. Der Opener war schlecht. Orlando vs Mathews war schlecht. Das letzte Match von Mathews der Backstage einige Schellen von Orlando kassierte und siegt dank Booker Ts Hilfe. Naja wenn es sein muss. Reigns und Jindrak vs RVD und Eddie war in Ordnung. Wie schon letzte Woche zeigen die Heels solide Vorstellungen. Eddie verkündet Cena als letztes Mitglied. Es gibt einen bedeutungslosen Staredown zwischen Heidenreich und Undertaker wo nichts weiter geschah. Der Main-Event war schlecht. Die Heels griffen ein da Big Show fast den Sieg holte. Zusätzlich sind die Heels auch in Überzahl und ließen die Faces am Ende liegen. Der Tough Enough Bullshit zieht die Show extrem runter."
[4.0] "This was miles better than last week because the matches were good outside of Mathews/Jordan, but the same bad storylines and Tough Enough were still dominant, and Mathews, the Velocity announcer, being a big part of the Survivor Series title match build is just terrible."
