[4.0] "Very disappointing Raw here, especially for an MSG show! While there is a very good match between Shawn Michaels and Christian that's worth watching, the rest of the show is kinda there and it's mostly heels complaining about the Taboo Tuesday PPV because that's a really good way to sell the event. The problem is I think it might have worked well on a standard episode of Raw or Smackdown in a similar way to the Raw Roulette show (well at least the first one anyway), but it's very hard to build towards a PPV with it because the focus is all over the place with multiple possible challengers for the World and particularly the IC title so it's pretty much impossible to build a proper feud around it. They don't really help themselves with some of the segments as they are all particularly weak viewing and the match quality other than the first one is terrible. The Kane v Snitsky feud is oddly entertaining in a farcical kind of way and it's probably because they used it to turn Kane in to a sympathetic face even though there is absolutely no reason to cheer for him in this whatsoever! Also 0/10 for Lita's acting in the interview segment. Also the Simon Dean videos are great fun."

[5.0] "A pretty flawed show, though not without amusement. Some of these storylines are so absurd as to be laughable, Kane and Snitsky taking the cake. Best match for me was actually Batista/Benoit."

[3.0] "Very boring show, with the match quality lacking outside of HBK/Christian and the main event being for the purpose of Orton looking like an Austin clone with a ton of RKOs to end the show. Poor effort all around."